Middle East Risks and Chinese Oversupply Expose Limits of Naphtha-Based Structure

Industry Weighs Solutions for Feedstock and Process Conversion

Shale Gas Ethane Emerges as an Alternative, but Infrastructure Remains a Challenge

Petroc

As instability in the Middle East intensifies and raw material price volatility increases, the domestic petrochemical industry, which has long relied on a naphtha-based structure, is now grappling with the challenge of securing alternative feedstocks. Recently, there have been calls within the industry to turn to ethane extracted from U.S. shale gas as an alternative. At the same time, a range of solutions—including process conversion—are being proposed, sparking a vigorous debate over the industry’s future direction.

Participants of the 'Decarbonization Strategy Forum to Overcome the Petrochemical Regional Crisis' held at the National Assembly Members' Office Building in Yeouido on the afternoon of the 17th are taking a commemorative photo. Photo by Seo Mideum

Participants of the 'Decarbonization Strategy Forum to Overcome the Petrochemical Regional Crisis' held at the National Assembly Members' Office Building in Yeouido on the afternoon of the 17th are taking a commemorative photo. Photo by Seo Mideum

View original image

According to the 'Decarbonization Strategy Forum for the Petrochemical Industry' held at the National Assembly Members' Office Building in Yeouido on the 17th, the limitations of a naphtha-centered structure and the necessity to switch to alternative feedstocks such as ethane have emerged as key issues. This is because raw material supply itself has become unstable and price volatility has increased, due to a combination of risks in the Middle East and logistics disruptions.


Kim Ahyoung, a researcher at Solutions for Our Climate, who delivered the keynote presentation, analyzed, "The petrochemical industry is entering a period of structural change, with global oversupply, sluggish demand, and carbon regulations all happening at the same time," adding, "It is becoming increasingly difficult to remain competitive with existing methods alone."


In particular, the naphtha cracking center (NCC)—a core process in the petrochemical industry—is highly dependent on raw material and energy costs, which are directly tied to cost competitiveness. On top of this, excessive supply from China is increasing restructuring pressure across the domestic sector.


Against this backdrop, shale gas-based ethane is emerging as a "practical alternative." Kim Dongha, Team Leader at HD Hyundai Chemical, who participated in the forum, commented, "Ethane is a competitive feedstock compared to naphtha in terms of price, yield, and carbon," adding, "It is a realistic solution that can simultaneously achieve carbon reduction and cost savings."


Indeed, ethane is considered to be less expensive than naphtha, delivers a higher ethylene yield, and emits relatively less carbon. In the United States and China, ethane-based production structures are already spreading and have become a means of securing competitiveness.


However, the industry also pointed out that transitioning to ethane is not easy to implement in the short term. There is no infrastructure in Korea for storing or transporting ethane, and existing NCC facilities are designed for naphtha, so additional technological development and investment would be required.


Jang Yonghee, Head of the Low Carbon Promotion Team at LG Chem, said, "While there is consensus on the direction of introducing ethane, there is absolutely no relevant infrastructure in Korea," adding, "Considering the burden of converting facilities and making investments, it will not be easy to apply this in the short term."


During the forum, solutions involving process conversion were also presented alongside feedstock switching. Park Jinsu, CEO of Planet, suggested converting to electrically powered NCC as an alternative, stating, "The petrochemical industry is facing dual pressures: oversupply from China and global carbon regulations," and pointing out, "It will be difficult to withstand these pressures with the current business model."


He continued, "Although switching to electrically powered processes entails a significant cost burden, in the long term, it will be the key variable determining industrial competitiveness," emphasizing, "Ultimately, what matters more than technology is energy prices and the policy environment."


In the end, the consensus is that solutions for the petrochemical industry are unlikely to converge on a single approach; rather, a combination of feedstock transition and process innovation is likely to unfold in parallel. Experts believe that in the short term, introducing ethane and expanding the use of recycled feedstocks, and in the mid- to long-term, shifting to electrically powered processes together—what they call a "composite strategy"—will be a realistic scenario.



Park Jinsu, CEO of Planet, remarked, "At this point, the more fundamental issue is how to restructure the cost structure, rather than whether or not to decarbonize," pointing out, "If the industry continues to rely on a naphtha-centered system, it is highly likely to fall behind in global competition." He added, "Ultimately, the speed of policy implementation and infrastructure development will determine the success or failure of industrial transformation."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing