[Choi Junyoung's World+] Hormuz and the Allies
Allies Forced to Shoulder the Aftermath of the Middle East War
Trump’s Litmus Test for South Korean Diplomacy
A Cool-Headed Assessment Over Unconditional Compliance
The dreaded bill we feared has finally arrived. U.S. President Donald Trump has demanded that his allies send their navies to the Strait of Hormuz. The countries targeted are South Korea, Japan, China, the United Kingdom, and France.
The U.S. is openly shifting the aftermath of the war, which began last month on the 28th when the U.S. and Israel attacked Iran, onto its allies. South Korea is already experiencing a range of challenges due to the ripple effects of the war started by the U.S., such as rising oil prices and inflation. We cannot simply comply, but at the same time, we cannot outright refuse the demand, given our ongoing reliance on U.S. Forces Korea in the face of North Korea's threats. However, it is precisely at moments like this that we must not fall into the trap of the binary choice between "dispatching troops or refusal." Rather than being pushed by immediate pressure into a hasty decision, we need to view the entire situation, read the broader trends, and calmly evaluate multiple options.
Since taking office, President Trump had declared that the U.S. would no longer engage in wars. The National Security Strategy announced in November last year also explicitly stated the policy of a phased withdrawal from the Middle East. Therefore, we must first consider why President Trump, who had maintained this stance, decided to attack Iran. Based on currently available information, President Trump launched the attack on Iran—something no previous U.S. president had dared—because he trusted Israeli intelligence, the overwhelming strike capability of the U.S. military, and the rapid target acquisition enabled by artificial intelligence (AI) technology. He was convinced that by crippling the Iranian leadership and core military assets, he could achieve his objectives in a short period, as with Venezuela. There was internal opposition: Vice President J.D. Vance argued that the move was inconsistent with the spirit of "MAGA," and Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Dan Kane warned that a prolonged conflict would be inevitable.
However, President Trump, intoxicated by his success in Venezuela, saw Iran as another easy target. The political skills of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who accurately assessed Trump's mindset and instilled optimistic expectations, undoubtedly had some influence as well.
The White House's original plan was to cement the Western Hemisphere, where the U.S. mainland is located, as America's sphere of influence and exclude competitors to solidify U.S. dominance. In comparison, the Middle East, having lost strategic importance, was seen as a region where the U.S. could weaken Iran, a threat to Israel, and then withdraw. Weakening Iran and Venezuela—the targets of American attacks—was also seen as a way to check China, which was another appealing aspect of the plan.
However, the fatal flaw in this strategy, which had worked successfully in Venezuela, was that it did not apply to a country like Iran, which has a completely different set of values and behavioral patterns. The dictator who had oppressed and impoverished his people has now become a sacred martyr. Iran is resisting by mobilizing all available means, including indiscriminate attacks on neighboring countries and the blockade of the Strait of Hormuz. With hardliners now in full control, the war has become protracted. President Trump is under pressure to quickly wrap up a war that is dragging on with little to show for it. The core of his exit strategy is the normalization of the Strait of Hormuz. Only by reopening the strait can he demonstrate to the world that the war is over.
Cornered, President Trump has reverted to the security strategy he originally proclaimed: Only those allies who defend themselves and fulfill their fair share of responsibilities deserve America’s security umbrella. Thanks to the shale revolution, the U.S. is now energy self-sufficient, and the Strait of Hormuz no longer holds vital national interest for America. Although 20% of the world's oil supply passes through this narrow strait, the countries truly dependent on it are Asian nations like South Korea, Japan, China, and India. President Trump is now demanding that those countries, which have long enjoyed the greatest benefits under America's protection, pay their fair share. The dispatch of warships has now become a litmus test for determining "who is a real ally."
Among the countries being asked to contribute, South Korea is in the weakest position. Europe, with its reduced dependence on Middle Eastern energy, has greater room to resist. China is certain to refuse from the outset. Japan can invoke its pacifist constitution, which prohibits involvement in conflict zones, as a shield. However, South Korea, which is highly dependent on Middle Eastern crude oil and liquefied natural gas (LNG), cannot easily refuse. If South Korea rejects the request, President Trump will likely ramp up pressure by threatening to withdraw U.S. Forces Korea or impose higher tariffs. Yet, simply complying with the demand is not the answer either. We must be wary of a framework that forces us to choose as if there are only two options: dispatching troops or refusal.
The most realistic argument we can present is the lack of appropriate naval assets. The pride of our navy, the Sejong the Great-class destroyers, boasts outstanding air defense capabilities but cannot be deployed elsewhere as long as the North Korean threat persists. The Chungmugong Yi Sun-sin-class destroyers have been used in overseas operations, but their defensive capabilities are inadequate for high-intensity battlefields where drones and ballistic missiles are in play. The Incheon-class frigates are not suitable for long-distance operations, and the Dokdo-class amphibious assault ships would be easy targets without sufficient air defense support. While we wish to cooperate, the hard truth is that our available forces have practical limitations. As embarrassing as it may be, this might be the most honest card we can play. Of course, in making this argument, we must also remember to propose alternatives, such as replenishment and supply ships.
The Iran war triggered by the U.S. and Israel is shaking not only the political landscape of the Middle East but also South Korea’s security and economic environment. We now need to shift our perception from that of a bystander to a direct stakeholder. President Trump’s rhetoric, which claims allies must comply when requested, is infuriating, but we must also face the reality that we cannot ignore it. However, being flustered or afraid of pressure should not drive us into making a hasty, binary decision. The real task for South Korean diplomacy now is to find a third path—a solution that can secure both our alliance and our national interests.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Choi Junyoung, Senior Expert (Global Policy and Law), Yulchon LLC
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.