Court Rules Dismissal Was Intentional
Krafton Says, "We Disagree with the Decision"

A U.S. court has ruled that Krafton’s dismissal of the former management team at Unknown Worlds, the developer of the 'Subnautica' series, constitutes unfair dismissal. Krafton stated that it "respectfully disagrees" with the decision.


Krafton logo. Provided by Krafton

Krafton logo. Provided by Krafton

View original image

According to the decision issued by the Delaware Court of Chancery on the 16th (local time), the court ordered Krafton to reinstate Ted Gill, former CEO of Unknown Worlds, and return studio operational authority related to Subnautica 2, including its release schedule. The court also ruled that the deadline for the conditional earnout bonus promised to Gill should be extended by 258 days—the duration of his dismissal. However, since Charlie Cleveland and Max McGuire, co-founders of Unknown Worlds, had already stepped away from day-to-day work, the court decided not to order their reinstatement. The court did not address the damages claimed by the former management team of Unknown Worlds.


According to the court’s decision, Krafton acquired Unknown Worlds in 2021 for an upfront payment of $500 million (approximately 746 billion won) and a conditional earnout of $250 million. The contract guaranteed operational control for key executives, including then-CEO Gill.


However, during development of Subnautica 2, conflicts arose between Krafton and Unknown Worlds. In July last year, Krafton dismissed Gill, Cleveland, McGuire, and other founding members, appointing Steve Papoutsis, CEO of Striking Distance Studios, as the new CEO. The reason for dismissal was cited as "lack of game quality." The dismissed executives argued that Krafton fired them to avoid paying the conditional earnout and filed a damages lawsuit.

US Court Rules "Krafton Unfairly Dismissed Unknown Worlds Management... Must Return Operational Authority" View original image

The court determined that Krafton intentionally dismissed the management team to avoid paying the conditional earnout. According to the ruling, Krafton CEO Changhan Kim expressed concerns about having entered into a faulty contract with Unknown Worlds and discussed the situation with ChatGPT, OpenAI’s generative AI model. Following ChatGPT’s advice, Krafton blocked Unknown Worlds’ authority to release Subnautica on the Steam game distribution platform, according to the court.


When the lawsuit was filed, Krafton changed the grounds for dismissal to management neglect and large-scale data downloads. However, the court found these were not valid reasons for termination. Cleveland had been focusing on film and TV adaptations based on Subnautica intellectual property, while McGuire was conducting research on games for autistic children. The court found that Krafton had long been aware of and tolerated these activities, and that they did not constitute neglect of work. As for the large-scale data downloads, the court ruled this was not intentional misconduct since the data was immediately returned at Krafton's request.



Krafton stated, "We respectfully disagree with the ruling and are considering various possible responses regarding our next steps." The company added, "This decision does not address the damages claim filed by the former management team of Unknown Worlds or the issue of additional performance-based compensation related to Subnautica 2. Legal proceedings on these matters are ongoing."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing