'Stock Price Suppression Prevention Act' Gains Momentum... Experts Say 'The Key Is Inheritance and Gift Tax Reform' [Shareholder Capitalism]③
Following the Commercial Act Revision, Debate Spreads to Inheritance and Gift Tax Reform
Enhancing Shareholder Value vs. Succession Burdens: "A Structural Dilemma for Korea"
Experts Divided Over Tax Rate Cuts and Institutional Reform
① The Era of the Revised Commercial Act Begins... March Shareholders' Meeting Keywords
② "Now Is the Last Chance"... Companies Go All Out to Defend Control Amid Law Revision
③ 'Stock Price Suppression Prevention Act' Gains Momentum... Experts Say "Key Is Inheritance and Gift Tax Reform"
④ "Ultimately, Institutions Must Move" — The Reality of the Stewardship Code
⑤ The Final Piece Is Disclosure Systems... "Need to Overhaul 'Outcome Disclosure' That Excludes Shareholders"
The government and the ruling party are pushing to revise the Inheritance and Gift Tax Act, with the so-called 'Stock Price Suppression Prevention Act' at the forefront, igniting a tax debate over corporate governance and succession structures. The discussion on corporate governance reform, prompted by the revised Commercial Act's focus on strengthening shareholder rights, is now expanding to include the reform of the inheritance and gift tax system.
In particular, the high inheritance and gift tax rates have been identified as the structural reason why Korean companies are forced to prioritize succession burdens over shareholder value, leading to claims that the entire system must be overhauled. However, concerns remain that easing inheritance taxes could spark controversy over "tax cuts for the rich," suggesting that the process is likely to be contentious going forward.
"Debate on Inheritance and Gift Tax Reform Is Unavoidable"
President Lee Jaemyung, immediately after the third amendment to the Commercial Act passed the National Assembly last month, identified the revision of the Inheritance and Gift Tax Act as the top priority for follow-up legislation. This move further supported the amendment bill (inheritance and gift tax revision) proposed by Lee Soyoung, a lawmaker from the Democratic Party, which aims to prevent companies from artificially suppressing stock prices to reduce inheritance tax burdens during corporate succession.
The core of the bill is to tax listed companies with a price-to-book ratio (PBR) below 0.8 at the time of inheritance or gift not based on the stock price, but instead using the valuation method for unlisted companies (fair value assessment of assets and earnings). In addition, this month, another bill (Capital Market Act amendment) proposed by Assemblywoman Kim Hyunjung requires listed companies with a PBR below 1 for more than two consecutive years to publicly disclose their corporate value enhancement plans. This two-track approach (Inheritance and Gift Tax Act and Capital Market Act) aims to prevent artificial stock price suppression.
However, both inside and outside the market, there are concerns that simply regulating the practice of suppressing stock prices during succession is not enough. Since domestic companies are structurally compelled to prioritize succession burdens over shareholder value, there are inevitable limitations unless the tax system itself changes. In the march toward shareholder capitalism, the debate on inheritance and gift tax reform is seen as an unavoidable issue.
Namwoo Lee, Chairman of the Korea Corporate Governance Forum, noted that the heavy inheritance tax burden is one reason for the conflicting interests between controlling and minority shareholders, stating, "While the Stock Price Suppression Prevention Act is also necessary, ultimately, rationalization of the inheritance and gift tax system is needed." However, he added, "There is a need to consider ways to reduce the inheritance tax burden, but this should come after a level playing field is established through improved corporate governance."
"Inheritance Tax Burden Distorts Governance" vs. "Tax Cuts for the Rich"
Tax experts are also raising the need for inheritance tax reform. South Korea’s top inheritance tax rate (50%) is the second highest among OECD member countries. In particular, for corporate shares, a 20% premium is added for major shareholders, resulting in a maximum rate of 60%. This is why the business community frequently complains of "punitive taxation."
Hong Kiyong, professor at the Department of Business Administration at Incheon National University, argued, "The inheritance tax must be revised. To make Korea a business-friendly country, no one would stay if the inheritance tax is 60%." Professor Hong also pointed out, "The current system does not meet global standards. Of the 38 OECD countries, 14 have no inheritance tax at all." Among OECD countries that do impose inheritance tax, the average rate is 25%. He insisted, "If it is difficult to lower the rate to the average, it should at least be reduced to the US level (40%)."
Kim Woochul, professor at the Department of Taxation at the University of Seoul, also stressed the need for reform, saying, "With the current inheritance tax, corporate succession is difficult and it negatively affects the country’s potential growth rate." He added, "The core problem is the high rates due to the premium for major shareholders and the punitive nature of the tax. The burden should be eased as in other countries. Reaching OECD standards would be beneficial, but for now, revising the rate structure is most important."
On the other hand, there is no shortage of critical perspectives. Kang Byunggoo, professor of economics at Inha University, countered, "Inheritance and gift taxes should be strengthened. While the rates are high, only 5% of heirs actually pay inheritance tax." He continued, "Owing to various deductions and exemptions, Korea's effective tax rate is low and the underground economy is large. The priority should be to make the tax base more realistic, rather than simply focusing on the rate." Yuholim, professor at Kangnam University’s Department of Taxation, also argued, "Saying inheritance and gift taxes are bad is just capital’s logic, which runs counter to tax justice and constitutional values." In the end, the concern is that reform could turn into a tax cut for the wealthy.
Compromise Measures Emerge Instead of Rate Cuts
As debate continues over lowering inheritance tax rates, compromise measures are gaining traction: abolishing the 20% premium for major shareholders, allowing payment in kind for listed stocks, and expanding business succession programs. Since cutting the inheritance tax rate is politically difficult, the idea is to first introduce institutional mechanisms that can ease the burden of corporate succession. Park Hoon, professor at the Department of Taxation at the University of Seoul, suggested, "Although Korea’s inheritance and gift taxes are high, some argue the effective rate is different, and relaxing the top rate is a politically divisive issue, so it’s difficult to push through. Therefore, broadening the abolition of major shareholder premium, which has already been eased for SMEs, might be a solution."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Experts are divided on whether tax reform would resolve the so-called "Korea discount." Professor Hong said, "Only by reforming the inheritance tax can the Korea discount (undervaluation of the Korean stock market) be addressed." In contrast, Professor Kim said, "There is little correlation with boosting stock prices, but the inheritance tax should be reformed according to its original intent and principles."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.