‘Redemption Rush’ Also Seen in Retail Real Estate Funds

Stabilization Only After Commercial Real Estate Price Adjustments

New Capital Inflows Also Contributed to Recovery

Time Needed for Price Adjustments in Credit Assets

Photo by Getty Images Bank

Photo by Getty Images Bank

View original image

Redemption requests for private credit funds in the United States are on the rise. Analysts note that in the past, similar redemption requests occurred with retail real estate funds, and that a significant portion of price adjustments in the underlying asset markets had already taken place before the situation stabilized.


On March 17, Hana Securities provided this analysis regarding the redemption situation in private credit funds. The way fund managers respond to redemption requests varies from firm to firm.


For example, Blue Owl Capital’s OBDC II fund ended its redemption structure and shifted to a capital return model. Blackstone’s BCRED product received redemption requests totaling 3.8 billion dollars, which is 7.9% of its assets. Although the contractual redemption limit was 5%, it was increased to 7%, and the remaining 0.9% was covered by the company’s capital and contributions from management. Despite the increase in redemption requests, the retail private credit funds of BlackRock and Cliffwater have been managing liquidity by applying limits.


Hana Securities emphasized the importance of looking at past cases involving retail real estate fund redemptions. In 2022, Blackstone’s BREIT and SREIT products saw a surge in redemption requests. Both funds were unlisted real estate funds targeting retail investors and allowed redemptions in accordance with specific schedules and conditions. Redemptions were permitted up to approximately 2% of the monthly net asset value (NAV) and 5% of the quarterly NAV. The funds’ holdings were commercial real estate (CRE), allowing for regular redemptions, but the assets were difficult to liquidate quickly. Thus, as with private credit funds, there was a structural liquidity mismatch.


Not only the product structure but also the pattern of the “redemption rush” at that time was similar. After 2022, as interest rates surged, the commercial real estate market collapsed, and growing anxiety led to a flood of redemption requests. Once these requests exceeded fund guidelines, redemptions for both BREIT and SREIT were restricted.


For BREIT, redemptions were restricted for about 15 months starting at the end of 2022. During this period, the commercial real estate market underwent asset price adjustments and portfolio restructuring. Afterward, from 2024, redemption requests decreased, and the fund returned to a normal redemption structure. A 4 billion dollar investment from University of California Investments also played a significant role in stabilizing the fund. Lee Youngjoo, a researcher at Hana Securities, explained, “Compared to immediately after the redemption restrictions for retail funds, the underlying asset markets had undergone significant price adjustments and new capital inflows began, which led to stabilization of redemptions.”

"Private Credit Redemption Pressure: Lessons from the Past Needed" View original image

Ultimately, it is expected that a similar pattern will emerge in the private credit market. While some funds are changing their structures or selling assets, others are maintaining liquidity and accepting redemption requests. Large institutional capital has not yet flowed in, as seen in the BREIT example. Major institutional investors appear to be keeping their options open regarding equity sales and are taking a wait-and-see approach.



Researcher Lee predicted, “A turning point in the private credit market is likely to become apparent in the process of asset sale prices during redemption responses, the trend of redemption requests in retail funds, and whether institutional capital flows in.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing