Statement Made in Front of About 10 Inmates in Prison Yard

Court: "Difficult to Recognize as Serving the Public Interest"

An inmate who pointed to a fellow prisoner and accused him of committing a child sex crime has been sentenced to a fine for defamation.


According to Yonhap News on March 14, citing legal sources, Judge Kim Bohyun of the Uijeongbu District Court's 9th Criminal Division sentenced inmate A to a fine of 1 million won on charges of defamation.


On October 11, 2024, at the exercise yard of Uijeongbu Prison in Uijeongbu, Gyeonggi Province, A was tried for defamation after telling fellow inmates that B, a male prisoner in his 50s, was a "sex offender." At the time, about 10 other inmates were reportedly present at the scene.


After A made the statement, other inmates asked, "Who is it?" A then pointed at B with his finger and said, "That short man over there wearing knee pads is the one who forced a minor under the age of 13 to perform a sexual act," according to the investigation.


Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

During the trial, A's side argued that A did not specifically mention B's name or inmate number, so B could not be clearly identified, and there was no intent to defame. They also contended that the incident occurred while reporting B's inappropriate behavior, and that A pointed to B to correct a misunderstanding when other inmates mistook the perpetrator for someone else.


However, the court found that, given the circumstances, the surrounding inmates could clearly recognize that B was the subject of the remarks.


The court stated, "Under the Criminal Act, if an act is entirely for the public interest, there is no punishment even if the facts are true," adding, "The defendant made statements about the victim in the prison yard in front of several people, and it is difficult to see that the content was solely for the public interest."


The court further ruled, "Considering the nature and context of the defendant's remarks, the amount of the fine set by the summary order is not considered excessive," and sentenced A to the same fine of 1 million won as in the summary order.



Under Article 307, Paragraph 1 of the current Criminal Act, anyone who publicly states facts that defame another person's reputation is subject to up to two years of imprisonment or detention, or a fine of up to 5 million won. However, there is an exception clause stating that there is no punishment if the statement concerns only the public interest and is true.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing