Deposit Embezzlement Targeting Elderly Landlords on the Rise
Bank Shifts Repayment Responsibility with a Single Registered Notice
Real Estate Agency Claims, "I Was Unaware of the Pledge Arrangement"

Mr. A (83), who has been renting out studio apartments in Gangnam-gu, Seoul for over 20 years, recently experienced an unfair situation. A tenant who had moved in with a jeonse loan absconded after embezzling a deposit of over 100 million won.


According to the police on March 16, the incident began in May 2023. Tenant Mr. B (33) signed a jeonse contract with a deposit of 140 million won and received a jeonse loan from a commercial bank. On the day of the real estate contract, the broker told landlord Mr. A, "You just need to sign to agree to the jeonse loan," and Mr. A signed without any suspicion.


However, at the time, Mr. A did not know that this contract involved the establishment of a "pledge (priority repayment right)." Simply put, if the tenant fails to repay the jeonse loan, the landlord is required to repay it on their behalf. The broker did not separately explain this to Mr. A at the time, and it was not specified in the contract.


After the contract, the bank sent a registered notice containing this information to Mr. A's address. However, Mr. A, who was unaware of its significance, thought it was just a routine notice and simply kept the letter.


Gemini Generated Image

Gemini Generated Image

View original image

The problem surfaced about two years later, in July last year. The bank contacted Mr. A, informing him that "the tenant is in arrears because he has not repaid the loan." Mr. A was understandably shocked, as he had already returned the deposit to Mr. B through the account specified by the tenant after B requested an early move-out. When he belatedly asked the real estate agent, he only received an irresponsible reply: "I didn't know it was that kind of (pledge) contract."


The elderly Mr. A had been running his rental business by directly returning the deposit to tenants upon their request when they moved out. Mr. B, too, had asked for the deposit to be returned, claiming that he needed to move out for personal reasons after just one year. Once again, Mr. A returned the deposit without suspicion. Mr. A lamented, "For 20 years, I returned deposits whenever tenants requested it, and there was never a problem before."


Looking at the messages sent by the absconded Mr. B, it is presumed that he squandered the stolen deposit on investments in virtual assets (cryptocurrency). He repeatedly made excuses such as, "I managed to save 500 million won in my early 30s, but I lost it all to bad investments," "I also lost the house my parents gave me, so I have nothing left," and "I will analyze the cause of my losses and try to get back on my feet." Despite embezzling the deposit, Mr. B expressed his intention to continue investing in cryptocurrency, causing anguish for his family.


After persistent contact efforts, Mr. A's side managed to summon tenant Mr. B to a law office at the end of August last year. Mr. A's daughter explained, "It was devastating to see the tenant, who used to drive a foreign car, show up heavily made up," and added, "The shock was even greater because my father passed away that August, and my mother's health also deteriorated."

Reconstruction of KakaoTalk conversation between landlord Mr. A (83) and tenant Mr. B (33) from last July.

Reconstruction of KakaoTalk conversation between landlord Mr. A (83) and tenant Mr. B (33) from last July.

View original image

At this meeting, Mr. B repaid 30 million won and notarized a promise to repay the remainder by October of that year. However, Mr. B then disappeared again, leaving more than 100 million won unpaid, and cut off all contact. The bank's demands continued, and in the end, Mr. A had to repay the principal and overdue interest on the loan left by the tenant in January of this year.


Last month, Mr. A filed a criminal complaint against tenant Mr. B for fraud at the Suseo Police Station in Seoul. The police began their investigation on March 13, starting with an interview with the complainant, and are looking into Mr. B's whereabouts and the circumstances of the deposit usage.


There are growing calls for measures to protect elderly landlords, as similar cases of tenants embezzling deposits from those unfamiliar with real estate-related regulations continue to occur.


An official from one local district office in Seoul said, "Cases like Mr. A's are not only occurring with residential properties but also with commercial spaces," and added, "Many elderly landlords who do not understand the structure of jeonse loans return deposits directly to tenants instead of to the bank account, and as a result, become victims of fraud."



Experts recommend the need for "in-person guidance" for the elderly. Attorney Oh Gidoo (Oh Gidoo Law Office) said, "It is possible to file a fraud charge against the tenant, but under the current system, it is difficult to hold the bank or brokerage accountable," emphasizing, "There is a need to strengthen procedures such as in-person guidance for elderly landlords."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing