"Severe Infringement on Shareholder Rights" VIP Asset Management Issues Warning to Daewon Industrial Over Cumulative Voting Exclusion
First-Ever Public Opposition to Shareholders' Meeting Agenda
"Directly Contradicting Prevailing Trends"
Succession of Third Generation and Allegations of Related-Party Transactions Raised
VIP Asset Management has openly opposed Daewon Industrial, a KOSDAQ-listed company, over its attempt to exclude the cumulative voting system. This marks the first time VIP Asset Management, which has previously conducted most of its shareholder engagement activities privately, has publicly opposed an agenda item at a shareholders' meeting. This underscores the firm's view that shareholder rights are being severely infringed.
On March 13, VIP Asset Management stated, "We believe that the agenda items proposed by Daewon Industrial's board for the upcoming shareholders' meeting pose a serious threat to the rights of general shareholders. As such, we will vote against certain items, including the proposed amendment to the Articles of Incorporation." VIP Asset Management, which manages approximately 10 trillion won in assets under management, is a leading domestic value investment asset manager that has long pursued a friendly activist approach.
VIP Asset Management first criticized Daewon Industrial for proposing an agenda item to include a clause excluding the cumulative voting system in its Articles of Incorporation at the shareholders' meeting scheduled for March 20. If this amendment passes, the possibility for minority shareholders to participate in the board of directors could be fundamentally blocked. The firm pointed out, "Since last year's revision of the Commercial Act, companies with total assets of 2 trillion won or more are required to adopt cumulative voting, strengthening minority shareholder rights. Daewon Industrial's move directly contradicts this prevailing trend."
The cumulative voting system, which will be implemented for companies with total assets of 2 trillion won or more from the second half of this year, allows shareholders to concentrate their voting rights on specific candidates, thereby enhancing the influence of minority shareholders on the board. Although Daewon Industrial's total assets amount to 750 billion won—below this threshold—the largest shareholder holds a 63% stake, making cumulative voting virtually the only means for minority shareholders to have a voice in the boardroom.
This type of exclusion clause is also opposed in principle by both domestic and international advisory institutions, such as the Korea ESG Standards Institute's proxy voting guidelines and the Korea Voting Guidelines from Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS), the world's largest proxy advisory firm.
In addition, VIP Asset Management expressed opposition to the first agenda item (approval of financial statements), which sets the shareholder return rate at a dividend payout ratio of about 7%, and to the fifth agenda item (approval of the maximum compensation for directors), which seeks to increase the cap on executive compensation from 2 billion won to 3 billion won despite no improvement in shareholder value.
VIP Asset Management criticized, "Daewon Industrial is in an extremely undervalued state, with its market capitalization at only 60% of its net cash holdings. The market points to the persistently low shareholder return rate as the main reason for this entrenched undervaluation." Some market watchers also analyze that this low shareholder return policy is linked to the succession process of Executive Vice President Heo Sunho (who holds a 3.59% stake), suggesting that the company may be keeping its stock price low to reduce inheritance and gift tax burdens.
The issue of opaque related-party transactions was also raised. VIP Asset Management noted that Okcheon Industrial, in which special related parties including Vice Chairman Heo hold more than 66% of the shares, generated 81% of its 2024 revenue through Daewon Industrial. Likewise, Daejin, in which special related parties including Chairman Heo Jaegun hold more than 85% of the shares, is generating 92.7% of its sales through transactions with Daewon Industrial and other related parties. The firm stressed, "This structure is highly likely to result in the profits of the listed company being allocated to the owner family rather than to all shareholders. This is why independent board oversight is more critical here than at any other listed company."
Previously, VIP Asset Management sent a shareholder letter requesting four actions: withdrawal of the proposed amendment to exclude cumulative voting; disclosure of measures to manage related-party transactions; presentation of a mid- to long-term shareholder return policy roadmap; and direct meetings with the board of directors.
Minguk Kim, CEO of VIP Asset Management, stated, "Despite having ample cash, Daewon Industrial continues to maintain a low single-digit shareholder return rate and persist in transactions with related-party companies, which raises concerns of tunneling. We are deeply concerned that this proposed amendment to the Articles of Incorporation is an intentional act to undermine shareholder trust."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
He added, "We are aware of the practical limitations posed by the overwhelming 63% stake held by the largest shareholder—a figure close to the threshold for special resolutions. However, as an institutional investor managing our clients' assets, we are determined to fulfill our responsibilities. We hope that even at this stage, Daewon Industrial's management will voluntarily withdraw the amendment to exclude cumulative voting, resolve the complex issue of related-party transactions, and present a clear value-up policy to restore market trust."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.