If Dismissed, a Second Constitutional Complaint Is Planned
"We Will Challenge the Filing Period Itself"

As the 'case for the cancellation of deportation and protection orders' became the first case of judicial petition, attention is focused on whether it will be referred to a substantive hearing.

On December 4 last year (local time), Harasta near Damascus, Syria, which was devastated by more than 13 years of civil war. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

On December 4 last year (local time), Harasta near Damascus, Syria, which was devastated by more than 13 years of civil war. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

According to the legal community on March 13, this petition is considered to align with the intent behind introducing the judicial petition system. A lawyer specializing in human rights commented, "Cases such as the deportation of foreigners are among the most representative cases of fundamental rights violations," adding, "Seeking remedies for such fundamental rights appears to be consistent with the purpose of introducing the judicial petition system."


However, the prevailing opinion among legal experts is that the petition is highly likely to be dismissed at the preliminary review stage. This is because, under the Constitutional Court Act, the petition must be filed 'within 30 days from the date the judgment is finalized.' In this case, the judgment was finalized on January 8, and 63 days had passed as of the date the system was implemented. Chajinah Cha, professor at Korea University School of Law, noted, "While laws such as the Administrative Litigation Act sometimes recognize exceptions if justifiable grounds exist, it appears difficult to establish objective criteria for cases that occurred before the law came into effect."


Lee Il, an attorney at the public interest law center APIL and the claimant's legal representative, argued that applying the filing period without exception infringes upon the right to a trial and the right to equality. Attorney Lee said, "If the petition is dismissed, we plan to file a separate constitutional complaint regarding the filing period itself."



The petitioner, identified as A, a Syrian national, fled the Syrian civil war that began in 2011 and entered Korea in 2013. Subsequently, he was indicted on charges including continuing to conduct business after his period of permitted activities outside his visa status had expired, and was sentenced to one year in prison. He was paroled in 2024, but received deportation and protection orders. He is currently living in a third country, separated from his spouse and children, who were attending school in Korea.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing