Explanation Provided on Evaluation Criteria Controversy for Private Consignment Management Service of the Comprehensive Complex


"Institutional Improvements to Enhance Competitiveness, Operational Capability, and Safety Management Compared to 2023"

On March 12, Changwon Special City in Gyeongnam stated its position regarding the change in evaluation criteria for the “Comprehensive Private Consignment Management Service for Changwon Municipal Solid Waste Recycling Complex,” which was raised during the administrative questions on March 10, emphasizing that the changes represent institutional improvements with reinforced safety management.

Changwon Special City Hall, Gyeongnam. Photo by Se-ryung Lee

Changwon Special City Hall, Gyeongnam. Photo by Se-ryung Lee

View original image

The city explained that some items in the detailed proposal evaluation criteria for the 2026 service contract have been adjusted compared to those for 2023, and that these adjustments were made to reflect the operational characteristics of the facility in accordance with institutional improvements and related regulatory procedures.


Regarding quantitative evaluation, the adjustment of the period for recognizing performance from 5 years to within 10 years was made to align with Chapter 4 of the “Guidelines for the Operation of Restricted Bidding for Local Government Bidding and Contract Execution,” which stipulates that the performance recognition period should be set within the most recent 10 years. This measure was taken to broaden the scope of eligible bidders.


The exclusion of points for participation by local companies was explained as follows: while points were awarded for participation by local companies in 2023, this item was excluded from the 2026 evaluation criteria in accordance with the revision of the “Guidelines for the Operation of Restricted Bidding for Local Government Bidding and Contract Execution.”


The item regarding the disposition status for the occurrence of serious disasters, which existed in 2023, was removed due to the inability to verify recent data. Instead, an item evaluating industrial accident rates was added, in accordance with the “Guide to Safety and Health Management for Contracted, Service, and Delegated Work” by Gyeongsangnam-do and the “Plan for Ensuring Safety and Health in Contracted, Service, and Delegated Projects Related to the Serious Accidents Punishment Act” by the Changwon City Safety Management Office.


The period for recognizing facts related to the disposition of improper contractors was adjusted from within 2 years prior to the bid announcement date to within 3 years. This measure was explained as a way to more strictly verify the public responsibility and contract performance reliability of operators of fundamental environmental facilities directly related to citizens' daily lives.


The method for evaluating performance in similar projects was also adjusted. In 2023, when participating as a consortium, the evaluation was based on the sum of each member’s operational performance multiplied by their participation ratio. For 2026, the evaluation will focus on the performance of the lead company.


This adjustment aims to evaluate the actual performance capability and integrated management competence of the lead company responsible for operations, while also encouraging broader participation from more companies. The city explained that, in fact, there was only a single consortium (the current operator) that submitted a bid in 2023, resulting in a successful bid rate of 99.5%.



Meanwhile, Changwon Special City stated, “In the process of selecting operators for fundamental environmental facilities directly related to citizens' daily lives, we will place top priority on transparency, fairness, and objectivity, and will faithfully adhere to the relevant standards and procedures.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing