"Why Can't You Drive All the Way Alone?"... Manual Intervention Needed at Every Trouble Spot [Korea-China-US Robotaxi Battle] ⑦
The Bitter Reality of K-Autonomous Driving
Manual Override in Child Protection Zones and Tourist Bus "Edge Cases"
A Ride on the Cheonggye Autonomous Shuttle and Gangnam Late-Night Robotaxi
Driverless taxis, known as "robotaxis," have emerged as a core element of future mobility. The competition has evolved beyond just technological prowess; it is now a "data supremacy war" focused on who can accumulate more driving data and generate tangible profits. China, with substantial government backing, is amassing vast amounts of data, while the United States is surging ahead with advanced artificial intelligence (AI) capabilities. In contrast, Korea, despite its world-class manufacturing capabilities, is struggling to accelerate commercialization due to various regulations and inadequate institutional frameworks. The Asia Business Daily is taking an in-depth look at unmanned driving sites in Beijing, China and Las Vegas, USA, the data strategies of big tech companies in both countries, and the current state of autonomous driving in Korea. Through a three-part series, we explore the global robotaxi battlefield and seek survival strategies for our industry.
On the 5th, the A01 autonomous shuttle boarded near Cheonggyecheon in Seoul. Photo by Youngchan Choi
View original image"Autonomous driving is not available in this area, so I will switch to manual driving."
At exactly 3:00 p.m. on March 5, not long after the A01 autonomous shuttle began its route near Cheonggyecheon in Seoul, it switched to manual driving. The reason was that the vehicle had entered a child protection zone. The test driver, who boarded together with the passengers, explained that by law, a human must drive in this section, and operated the vehicle using a separate controller, as the shuttle is not equipped with a steering wheel.
Even when departing from the initial stop, the test driver manually controlled the vehicle to enter the lane. There were several other situations throughout the ride, even after passing the child protection zone, where the driver had to intervene.
The Cheonggye A01 route covers a round-trip distance of 4.8 kilometers, with two vehicles circulating and stopping at a total of 11 stations in both directions. According to the driver, the vehicle typically does not stop at the Bangsan Market station. This is because, after stopping at the station, the vehicle must enter the left-turn lane, and the complex road environment in front of Cheonggyecheon currently presents limits for autonomous driving to handle on its own.
Inside the A01 autonomous shuttle boarded near Cheonggyecheon in Seoul on the 5th. Photo by Youngchan Choi
View original imageAfter the vehicle successfully made a left turn past Bangsan Market station, it soon faced another left turn. At this point, an "edge case" occurred—a tour bus was blocking the left-turn lane by tailgating. Observers wanted to see how the autonomous driving system would respond, but the test driver immediately grabbed the controller without hesitation.
Due to the complicated road conditions, several more manual interventions were required, and there was even a period of three minutes of continuous manual driving. Stopping at the designated drop-off point also ultimately required the driver's involvement.
The Cheonggye A01 route experienced that day is characterized by narrow roads where jaywalking pedestrians frequently appeared. The vehicle, operated by Autonomous A2Z, was able to detect pedestrians from a distance, slow down, and come to a stop. When a pedestrian appeared in front of the vehicle ahead, it recognized the situation in advance and stopped smoothly, without any abrupt stops or sudden acceleration.
The Cheonggye A01 cannot be considered completely autonomous, as it only travels along a designated route and stops at fixed stations. Frequent human intervention was required due to the 30 km/h speed limit, manual operation regulations within child protection zones, and the need to adjust to the flow of other vehicles. There was no flexibility in the road environment to allow the autonomous vehicle to handle unexpected situations on its own.
A similar situation was observed on another day with a late-night autonomous vehicle operating in Seoul’s Gangnam area (operated by SWM). Operating from 11:00 p.m. to 5:00 a.m., this vehicle served passenger-designated pick-up and drop-off points on certain dark and complex roads in Gangnam.
On the 9th, a Seoul Autonomous Car was boarded near Apgujeong Station in Seoul. Photo by Youngchan Choi
View original imageEven at the speed limit of 50 km/h, it drove stably, making smooth left turns and lane changes. When the car in front stopped with its hazard lights on, the vehicle slowed down and naturally changed lanes.
However, this vehicle also required frequent intervention by the test driver, making it impossible to witness the autonomous driving software operating entirely on its own from start to finish. While domestic autonomous driving technology is not yet fully developed, excessive regulations and ambiguous legal responsibilities are hindering technological progress.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
An industry official explained, "Under current law, test drivers are classified as emotional laborers due to 24-hour in-vehicle recordings, leading to high psychological stress. This also makes it difficult for autonomous driving operators to demand aggressive autonomous driving from these drivers. Furthermore, since legal responsibilities are unclear in the event of an accident, even a minor risk prompts the driver to take the wheel."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.