Four Key Areas for Essential Evaluation

Korea Deloitte Group has proposed essential areas that corporate audit committees and external auditors should focus on and evaluate together as the annual shareholder meeting season approaches.


On March 12, the Center for Corporate Governance Advancement at Korea Deloitte Group, in its publication "Corporate Governance Insights No. 13," highlighted the following areas: ▲uncertainties in key accounting judgments and estimates, ▲effectiveness of internal controls and financial reporting risks, ▲management attitudes and risks of financial fraud, and ▲limitations of audit scope and residual risks.


Yoo Minji, partner in the Audit Division at Korea Deloitte Group and author of the report, stated, "As the complexity of accounting judgments increases and internal controls are increasingly systematized, the role of audit committees is expanding." She emphasized, "Therefore, communication with external auditors must lead to substantive oversight, with audit committees asking key questions that get to the heart of their responsibilities."


First, regarding uncertainties in key accounting judgments and estimates, she explained that for items such as impairment losses, it is more important to verify the rationality of the decision-making process than to focus on the final figures. She added that audit committees should check for changes in assumptions compared to the previous year and whether there are any disagreements between the company and the external auditor.


In terms of internal control effectiveness and financial reporting risks, she warned that reliance on specific individuals or weaknesses in IT and data controls can lead to financial reporting distortions. Therefore, audit committees must examine delayed improvements in internal control deficiencies and deficiencies that are highly likely to cause distortions in financial reporting.


Regarding management attitude and financial fraud risks, she analyzed that recent cases of financial fraud have resulted from a combination of formalistic controls and management attitudes. The audit committee should therefore verify the appropriateness of management reporting and identify weaknesses in controls over fund execution and account management.


In addition, the report explained that given the inherent limitations of audit procedures, audit committees need to recognize "residual risks" and derive tasks for future improvement. This includes reviewing areas that could not be audited due to audit restrictions or areas where obtaining audit evidence was difficult.


The report also suggested the possibility of insufficient sharing of perspectives on the same risks between audit committees and external auditors. For the 2024 fiscal year, out of 86 companies where external auditors issued qualified opinions on the internal accounting management system, audit committees at 76 companies (about 90%) issued unqualified opinions. The report defined the relationship between audit committees and external auditors as a "healthy tension," emphasizing that audit committees can enhance their practical supervisory function by asking critical questions.


The report also addressed the potential impact of the financial authorities' stewardship code enhancement measures on the 2026 regular shareholder meetings. Based on the enhancement measures announced in December of last year, it is expected that institutional investors' voting and engagement activities will transition to a "recordable and explainable" approach. Corporate responses to shareholder meetings may also expand to include a review of governance decision-making standards and record-keeping and management systems.


For the 2026 shareholder meetings, the report identified the following as key issues for each agenda item: ▲procedures and criteria for shareholder return policy decisions as well as plans for improving TSR, PBR, and ROE; ▲appropriateness of reflecting revisions to the Commercial Act and impact on shareholder rights; ▲actual independence, expertise, and board contributions of director and auditor (committee member) candidates; and ▲specificity of compensation policies and conflict-of-interest management plans.



The full report is available on the Korea Deloitte Group website. Hanseok Kim, Head of the Center for Corporate Governance Advancement at Korea Deloitte Group, emphasized, "This year's regular shareholder meetings can serve as an opportunity to examine the decision-making standards and record-keeping and management systems of boards and audit committees. Governance bodies should ensure consistency, foundation, and procedural transparency when reviewing and supervising related matters."

Deloitte: "Essential Communication Between Audit Committees and External Auditors... Key Areas to Check" View original image


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing