"Rituals with Religious Significance Should Be Avoided"

"Infringement on Freedom of Conscience"... Recommendation for Improvement

The National Human Rights Commission of Korea has recommended improvements, stating that the practice of having students shout a specific slogan and perform a salute at private middle school events may infringe on students' fundamental rights.


National Human Rights Commission of Korea, Jung-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

National Human Rights Commission of Korea, Jung-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

View original image

On March 12, the Commission announced that it had determined the tradition of requiring students to chant the slogan "Gyeongcheon" (敬天, reverence for heaven) and perform a salute during school events infringes on students' general freedom of behavior, freedom of religion, and freedom of conscience. In January, the Commission recommended that the principal of the school refrain from this practice.


A graduate of the school filed a petition in October last year, stating, "This practice could constitute a violation of the human rights of current students." The school explained that the tradition is part of education to put into practice the values of its motto—“Gyeongcheon, Aeguk, Aein” (reverence for heaven, patriotism, love for others)—and that it carries no religious significance. The school further stated that students are not penalized or disciplined if they do not participate in the chant or salute, and that most students supported maintaining the tradition in a student council discussion.


However, the Commission viewed this as a ceremonial act that all students are required to repeatedly perform in the same manner at official school events. It also determined that “Gyeongcheon” can be interpreted as honoring God, and that pairing this with a symbolic salute further reinforces its religious connotation. The Commission concluded that this goes beyond simple etiquette education and amounts to requiring students to express specific values and beliefs.


The Commission also pointed out that a student council decision cannot by itself justify restricting individual students' fundamental rights. Middle school students, due to their developmental stage, are susceptible to school authority and peer pressure, making it difficult for them to refuse such acts. If the act in question may include religious meaning, sufficient review of individual students' rights to refuse and the scope of teachers' guidance is necessary.



A representative of the Commission stated, "We hope that this recommendation serves as an opportunity to create an environment in schools where students can learn equally, regardless of their religious beliefs."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing