Bankruptcy Trustees and Rehabilitation Commissioners:
External Experts Handling Court Operations
Concerns Over High-Handed Attitudes and Professionalism
Lack of Oversight and Supervision
Bar Association Plans Oversight Similar to "Judge Evalua

[Exclusive] Bankruptcy Trustees, CROs, and Rehabilitation Commissioners to Be Evaluated by the Bar Association View original image

The Korean Bar Association has decided to evaluate the performance of key figures in insolvency proceedings—such as bankruptcy trustees and personal rehabilitation commissioners—who are often referred to as “keymen” in these procedures. The aim is to introduce a similar system of checks and balances for them as the “judicial evaluation” conducted annually for judges, which assesses their attitude in court.


According to a report by The Asia Business Daily on March 12, the Insolvency Lawyers Society of the Korean Bar Association has begun drafting preliminary evaluation criteria to assess the work performance of bankruptcy trustees, personal rehabilitation commissioners, Chief Restructuring Officers (CROs), and supervisory committee members, focusing on specific real-life cases.


These professionals are external experts who handle practical work on behalf of the court. Bankruptcy trustees and rehabilitation commissioners investigate the debtor’s financial status and provide decisive evidence to judges regarding eligibility for debt discharge. Likewise, CROs and supervisory committee members involved in corporate rehabilitation have the authority to approve fund disbursements and effectively control the fate of a company. This is why, among those undergoing insolvency proceedings, there is a saying that “insolvency assistants appointed by the court are scarier than the judges.” Insolvency assistants typically consist of lawyers, accountants, and former financial professionals, and are directly appointed by the court from a managed pool of experts.


The problem is that, while these professionals wield significant influence under delegated court authority, they remain largely outside the scope of oversight and supervision. The selection process is closed, and once a person is on the list, their appointment is maintained unless there is a major fault. Given the extensive authority they exercise, these assistants are often regarded as the de facto “power holders” in the field. However, there have been criticisms that some assistants’ high-handed attitudes, unprofessional work, or excessive requests for additional documentation have directly resulted in delays and hardships for debtors during the insolvency process.


To address this, the Bar Association intends to establish a system to objectively verify the proficiency and quality of service of these professionals. Instead of relying on numerical scores or ratings, they have decided to accumulate specific case examples from actual work processes. Through this, they aim to build an information-sharing system and distinguish between experts whose competence has been validated and those who have not.



Meanwhile, since 2008, the Korean Bar Association has conducted annual “judicial evaluations” of judges nationwide, assessing their court attitude and expertise. Although there were concerns at the outset that this might infringe upon judicial independence, after 18 years of implementation, it is credited with improving the quality of trials, including a noticeable decrease in so-called “abusive judges” who frequently engage in high-handed or inappropriate behavior.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing