Practical Preparations Completed, Including Formation of Dedicated Review Panel

"Not a Hierarchical Relationship with the Courts... Only 'Annulment' of Judgments"

The Constitutional Court emphasized its primary function of protecting fundamental rights, drawing a clear line against concerns such as the so-called "fourth instance system," which have been raised as even final Supreme Court rulings, the highest level of the judiciary, are now subject to review by the Constitutional Court.


Sun Inhyuk, Secretary General of the Constitutional Court, is speaking about constitutional petitions at a press conference held on the 10th at the annex of the Constitutional Court in Jongno-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

Sun Inhyuk, Secretary General of the Constitutional Court, is speaking about constitutional petitions at a press conference held on the 10th at the annex of the Constitutional Court in Jongno-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

View original image

On the afternoon of March 10, Sun Inhyuk, Secretary General of the Constitutional Court, held a press conference in the briefing room at the annex of the Constitutional Court in Jongno-gu, Seoul. He explained the purpose behind the introduction of the constitutional petition system and the current preparations, stating, "We are taking steps to prevent the negative effects of a so-called 'fourth instance system' from occurring."


Secretary General Sun stated, "Constitutional complaints have served to protect the fundamental rights of citizens from public authority and to monitor the legislative, executive, and judicial branches so that state power does not deviate from constitutional principles. However, there has been no oversight of court trials, which have the most direct impact on individuals." He added, "We will strive to ensure efficient cooperation between the courts and the Constitutional Court."


He further emphasized, "The judicial tier system will become more deliberative, and the constitutional petition system will establish a more robust framework for guaranteeing fundamental rights."


In preparation for the implementation of the constitutional petition system, the Constitutional Court held a meeting of the justices on March 3 to discuss matters such as case numbering, case assignment methods, and electronic processing procedures. It was decided that the case number for constitutional petition cases will use '헌마' (Heonma), the same designation as existing constitutional complaint cases.


A dedicated review panel for constitutional petition cases has also been organized. This panel is comprised of eight Constitutional Court research officials, each with over 15 years of legal experience.


Administrative preparations at the Secretariat level are also underway. Last week, the Constitutional Court launched an administrative preparation team of about 10 members to check the readiness for operating the constitutional petition system.


Procedurally, the Constitutional Court is prioritizing the revision of rules that require immediate amendment, such as the implementation rules and assignment regulations. Amendments to the Constitutional Court’s adjudication rules, which include additional requirements and attachments for constitutional petition cases, will also be implemented in line with the promulgation of the relevant law.


The system for electronic filing has already been established. The Constitutional Court will post guidance on how to file constitutional petitions and the required information on its website, and will produce informational leaflets for telephone and in-person consultations. Additionally, the Constitutional Court is working with the budget authorities to prepare for a potential increase in constitutional petition cases, including discussions on expanding research staff and securing the necessary budget.


A cooperative framework with the courts and the prosecution will also be established. The Constitutional Court explained, "In accordance with Article 32 of the Constitutional Court Act, we may request the courts to submit records or provide materials necessary for the review of constitutional petitions," adding that such consultations will be ongoing.


The Constitutional Court also rejected concerns that it would become a "superior institution" above the Supreme Court. The Court clarified that it does not function as a lower court that re-examines factual matters, but rather as a constitutional tribunal that only examines violations of the Constitution. When a constitutional petition is upheld, the Constitutional Court does not order the lower courts to retry or remand cases, as the Supreme Court does. Out of respect for the courts, the Constitutional Court only "cancels" the relevant ruling, and the original court is then obligated to hold a new trial on its own in accordance with the binding force of the Constitutional Court’s decision and existing procedural law. This is described as a system of constitutional oversight based on mutual respect and checks and balances, rather than a hierarchical relationship.


Regarding concerns that canceling a judgment could create legal controversies such as "double marriage" if a person who has already remarried has their divorce ruling invalidated, the Constitutional Court explained, "This is not a completely new legal issue arising from the constitutional petition system." The Court noted that, even now, there are cases where divorces or auctions are canceled in court retrial proceedings, and such matters can be adequately addressed within the existing precedents and judicial system.



Meanwhile, the law introducing the constitutional petition system (amendment to the Constitutional Court Act), which was approved at the Cabinet meeting on March 5, is scheduled to take effect immediately upon promulgation this week. Once the system is implemented, even final judgments confirmed by the Supreme Court—the last instance of the judiciary—can be canceled by the Constitutional Court if a violation of fundamental rights is found.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing