"Fundamental Rights Left Unprotected in Court Rulings"

Purpose of Introducing the Trial Petition System Explained

Even Supreme Court Rulings May Be Overturned by the Constitutional Court if Fundamental Rights Are Violated

Dedicated Re

Yonhap News

Yonhap News

View original image

Son Inhyuk, Secretary-General of the Constitutional Court, stated on March 10 that preparations are being made to prevent any negative side effects of the so-called “fourth-instance” system as the new trial petition system is implemented.


The Constitutional Court held a press briefing at its annex in Jongno-gu, Seoul, on the afternoon of the same day, explaining the purpose behind introducing the trial petition system and the current state of preparations.


Secretary-General Son said, “The constitutional complaint has served to protect the fundamental rights of citizens from state power and to monitor the legislative, executive, and judicial branches to ensure they do not deviate from constitutional principles. However, there has been no such monitoring over court rulings, which have the most direct impact.” He added, “We will strive for effective collaboration between the courts and the Constitutional Court.”


He also emphasized, “The court's appellate system will become more prudent, while the trial petition system will establish a more comprehensive framework for protecting fundamental rights.”


In advance of implementing the trial petition system, the Constitutional Court convened a meeting of justices on March 3 to discuss issues such as case numbering, case assignment methods, and electronic processing procedures. It was decided that the case number for trial petitions will use 'Heonma,' the same as for existing constitutional complaints.


A dedicated review panel for trial petition cases has also been formed. The panel consists of eight Constitutional Court research officials, each with more than 15 years of legal experience.


Administrative preparations at the Secretariat level are also ongoing. Last week, the Constitutional Court launched an administrative preparation team of about ten members to review and ensure readiness for the operation of the trial petition system.


Procedurally, the court is prioritizing the revision of rules that require immediate updates, such as the Constitutional Court's implementation rules and internal case assignment regulations. Amendments to the Constitutional Court's adjudication rules, which will add details on required entries and documents for trial petition cases, are scheduled to take effect when the legislative amendment is promulgated.


The system for electronic filing has already been completed. The Constitutional Court's website provides instructions on how to file a trial petition and the required entries for the petition form. In preparation for telephone and in-person inquiries, informational leaflets will also be produced and made available. In addition, the Constitutional Court is coordinating with the budget authorities to secure additional research staff and funding, anticipating a potential increase in adjudication cases following the introduction of the trial petition system.


A cooperative framework with the courts and the prosecution will also be established. The Constitutional Court explained, “According to Article 32 of the Constitutional Court Act, the Court may request the submission of records or materials from the courts if needed for the review of trial petitions,” adding that related consultations will be ongoing.



The legislation introducing the trial petition system (the amendment to the Constitutional Court Act), which was approved by the Cabinet on March 5, is scheduled to take effect immediately upon promulgation this week. Once the system is in place, even Supreme Court rulings that are final may be overturned by the Constitutional Court if they are found to infringe on fundamental rights.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing