Recommendation to Oppose Chairman Choi’s Reappointment as Inside Director
Capital Increase Controversy and Allegations of Illegal Cross-Shareholdings
ISS: "Restoring Checks and Balances on the Board Is Essential"

ISS, the world’s largest proxy advisory firm, has recommended voting against the reappointment of Chairman Choi Yoonbum as an inside director at the upcoming Korea Zinc annual general shareholders’ meeting scheduled for March 24. ISS assessed that the company’s funds and shareholding structure have essentially served as a shield for the chairman’s personal control over management.


According to the investment banking industry on March 10, ISS expressed this opinion in its agenda analysis report on the Korea Zinc annual general shareholders’ meeting released on the same day.


An information sign is installed at the entrance of Korea Zinc's annual general meeting held last March at the Mondrian Hotel in Yongsan-gu, Seoul.

An information sign is installed at the entrance of Korea Zinc's annual general meeting held last March at the Mondrian Hotel in Yongsan-gu, Seoul.

View original image

ISS recommended approval for the agenda item on electing five directors through cumulative voting. On the premise of cumulative voting, ISS expressed its support for all five nominees: Hwang Deoknam, Chairman of the Board nominated by Korea Zinc; Walter Field McLellan, nominated as an outside non-executive director by the U.S. Crucible JV; and Park Byungwook, Choi Byungil, and Lee Seonsook, all nominated by Young Poong and MBK Partners.


In contrast, ISS recommended voting against the reappointment of Chairman Choi as an inside director. Chairman Choi is standing for reappointment as an inside director for a two-year term at this annual general meeting.


In its report, ISS acknowledged Korea Zinc’s improved performance and rising stock price in recent years, but emphasized that the core issue in this case is not performance, but “governance structure.” The report cited several issues: Korea Zinc’s attempt to proceed with a low-priced rights offering after buying back treasury shares at a high price, controversy over the restriction of voting rights for Young Poong through the creation of illegal cross-shareholdings, and problems with the board approval process for large-scale strategic investments.


These developments have, in effect, used company funds and the shareholding structure as a shield for Chairman Choi’s personal control over management. This is interpreted as the formalization of the international investment community’s structural distrust of the current management system.


ISS also highlighted issues with a structure that grants non-executive honorary chairmen, who do not bear legal responsibility, retirement pay calculated at four times the standard applied to the CEO, and recommended approval of an amendment to the relevant regulations. ISS found it difficult to view the large compensation paid to the two honorary chairmen, who are family members of Chairman Choi, as consistent with global governance principles. In response to the company’s claim that such payments have been approved at previous shareholders’ meetings, ISS clarified that mere shareholder approval does not automatically guarantee the appropriateness of these measures.


ISS stressed that what is most needed at this time is to restore checks and balances. ISS believes that a board comprised of independent and professional directors can put an end to the repeated controversies and help restore investor trust.


Industry observers see this shareholders’ meeting as a critical turning point for determining whether Korea Zinc’s governance structure will shift to meet international standards.



Currently, Young Poong and MBK Partners hold a combined voting stake of 42.1%. Chairman Choi’s family and friendly shareholders, such as Hanwha and LG Chem, collectively hold 27.9%. The U.S. JV, considered an ally of Chairman Choi, holds a 10.8% stake. As the gap between the two blocs is narrow, it is expected that the direction of the shareholders’ meeting will be determined by the remaining approximately 19% of shares held by the National Pension Service, foreign institutional investors, and individual shareholders.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing