SK Rent-a-Car Fails to Attract Buyers

Lotte Rental Deal Faces Regulatory and Public Backlash

Affinity's Calculations Grow Complicated, Acquisition May Be Reconsidered

The private equity fund (PEF) manager Affinity Equity Partners is facing increasing concerns over its car rental business. After the Korea Fair Trade Commission (KFTC) rejected the business combination between Lotte Rental and SK Rent-a-Car, Affinity put SK Rent-a-Car up for sale. However, the market response has been lukewarm. Industry insiders speculate that Affinity is cautiously weighing the possibility of abandoning its pursuit of acquiring Lotte Rental altogether.


According to the investment banking (IB) industry as of March 10, Affinity is seeking a buyer for SK Rent-a-Car. Although sale proposals have been presented to major domestic asset management firms, the responses have reportedly been tepid. An executive at a leading Korean private equity firm said, "We reviewed the proposal but decided to pass, as it did not seem like an attractive asset. Even if someone acquires it, Affinity, which likely already has full knowledge of SK Rent-a-Car's internal information, would have to compete with Lotte Rental, currently the industry leader." The prevailing sentiment is that unless the acquisition is made at a significantly discounted price, it will be difficult to recover the investment later on.


There are also predictions within the industry that if the transaction continues to falter, Affinity could reconsider the terms of the Lotte Rental deal or even withdraw from the acquisition. This is because Affinity is already at the center of substantial regulatory risk, something that limited partners (LPs) are most wary of.


The first variable is the Commercial Act. With a revised Commercial Act passed that requires directors to protect the interests of all shareholders and ensure fair treatment, Affinity was criticized for providing the majority shareholder of Lotte Rental with an excessive "management rights premium."


Last year, Affinity agreed to acquire a 56.2% stake in Lotte Group, the majority shareholder of Lotte Rental, at 77,000 won per share, setting a premium of more than 160% over the then-market price of 29,000 won. In contrast, the price for the rights offering to ordinary shareholders was only 29,180 won. Coupled with the KFTC's decision to block the SK Rent-a-Car and Lotte Rental merger, the deal is seen as being in direct conflict with the current government’s stance on protecting minority shareholders and its opposition to monopolies and collusion.


Some speculate that Affinity may actually be hoping for LPs to demand the termination of the deal first. An IB industry insider commented, "Deals with conglomerates are usually conducted discreetly, but despite reaching this stage, the controversy keeps surfacing. It could be a signal meant to prompt both domestic and international LPs to recognize the situation and actually encourage withdrawal from the deal." The explanation is that SK Rent-a-Car remains competitive in the market, and since Affinity was able to analyze Lotte Rental's business structure and internal information during the process, the firm could be confident in raising SK Rent-a-Car's corporate value going forward.



In particular, it is analyzed that Affinity's financial burden may not be significant in terms of cost. If the transaction falls through due to a simple change of heart by the buyer, a penalty may be incurred. However, in cases like this, where the deal is subject to KFTC merger review, it is common for contracts to include clauses allowing the transaction to be withdrawn depending on the outcome of the regulatory review. A domestic private equity executive stated, "Given how far things have progressed, this appears to be a buyer-favorable deal. If the deal is withdrawn, it will be Lotte Group—already in a difficult financial situation—that will face the real crisis."

Affinity in Search of an Exit... May Abandon Lotte Rental Deal View original image


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing