Board of Audit and Inspection: "Decommissioned Freight Trains Still Operating... Negligence in Addressing Drunk Train Operators"
"Inspection of Railway Facility Safety Management Practices" Audit
Sininansan Line: Arbitrary Relaxation of Settlement and Other Standards
Five Decommissioned Freight Cars Operated 22 Times
Unauthorized Extension of Maintenance Cycles Also Detected
The Board of Audit and Inspection has uncovered a wide range of structural deficiencies in overall railway safety management, including the arbitrary relaxation of measurement management standards at the Sininansan Line construction site, continued operation of railway vehicles designated for decommissioning, unauthorized changes to railway vehicle maintenance cycles, neglect of suspected drunk driving by train operators, and omission of railway accident reports. An audit conducted after major incidents, such as the Sininansan Line tunnel collapse and the Yongsan Station freight train derailment, revealed that safety control was lax throughout the construction, operation, and supervision processes.
In the results of the "Inspection of Railway Facility Safety Management Practices," which were released to the public on March 9, the Board of Audit and Inspection stated that it had identified a total of 45 issues that threaten public safety and requested improvement measures. These included three disciplinary actions, 23 cautions, and 19 notifications.
The most prominent issue identified was at the Sininansan Line double-track railway private investment project site. According to the Board of Audit and Inspection, if the settlement amount or groundwater level change specified in the detailed design approved by the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, and Transport exceeds the standard value, construction must be suspended and a safety plan must be established after analyzing the cause. However, the construction company continued construction by processing the measurements for three work sections as if the ground settlement was within 10 mm, even though there were confirmed cases of the ground sinking up to 317 mm or rising up to 233 mm. The supervisory company also failed to properly verify these facts.
Groundwater level management was also poor. In principle, the initial measurement value before excavation should be used as the standard, but in three work sections, measurements taken during excavation were set as new standards, resulting in a relaxation of management criteria by 2 to 5.8 meters. From January 2021 to March of last year, supervisory companies for nine work sections arbitrarily lowered the ground settlement management standards without prior review or approval from the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, and Transport. The project operator, citing concerns about losses due to construction delays, arbitrarily relaxed groundwater level management standards for six work sections while proceeding with construction. In three work sections, the frequency of groundwater level measurements was reduced from once per day to once or twice per week.
On-site inspections by the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, and Transport and local governments were also inadequate. The Ministry approved changes to groundwater level management standards made by the project operator between November 2021 and May 2023 without sufficiently verifying the occurrence of ground settlement. Nine local governments—Gwangmyeong, Siheung, Ansan, Anyang, and the Guro, Geumcheon, Gwanak, Dongjak, and Yeongdeungpo districts of Seoul—failed to conduct the required annual measurement management inspections even once since September 2020, citing the project operator's failure to submit an underground safety management plan. The Board of Audit and Inspection notified the Ministry to take measures such as penalty points, business suspension, or criminal charges against the project operator, construction company, and supervisory company.
It was also confirmed that railway vehicles deemed unfit for operation continued to run on the tracks. Korea Railroad Corporation (Korail) conducted detailed safety inspections on 1,651 railway cars between 2019 and 2024, and 27 freight cars were found to be "unfit for operation" and subject to decommissioning. However, the responsible staff either did not inform the operations department or failed to take necessary actions after receiving notification from the inspection company. As a result, five decommissioned freight cars were used in a total of 22 operations. The Board of Audit and Inspection requested disciplinary action against those involved at Korail and notified the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, and Transport to prepare measures for criminal charges against those responsible.
Management of maintenance organizations was also lax. Korea Railroad Corporation is required to obtain change certification or submit change notifications to the Ministry whenever there is a change in maintenance depot staffing, but staff failed to do so and continued maintenance operations for a long period. From January 2022 to May 2023, 20,620 maintenance actions were performed at 12 vehicle depots without approval, and from October 2023 to April 2024, 45,713 maintenance actions took place at 16 vehicle depots without authorization. The Board of Audit and Inspection also found evidence that some staff interfered with the audit by falsifying document dates and contents in an attempt to shift responsibility to the Ministry. The Ministry, despite being aware of these facts, did not consider administrative actions such as corrective orders or fines.
The maintenance cycle for disassembling railway vehicle parts was also arbitrarily changed. According to the Board of Audit and Inspection, Korea Railroad Corporation and SR arbitrarily removed major components from maintenance cycle management without ministry approval in 172 cases, and extended maintenance cycles without authorization in 128 cases. For example, Korea Railroad Corporation unilaterally changed the maintenance cycle for KTX train bearings from 1.8 million km to 2.1 million km, and the bearing failed after 1.87 million km, leading to a train delay incident in August 2022. The Board of Audit and Inspection notified the Ministry to prepare fines against Korail and SR.
The train operator alcohol testing system was also found to be essentially neglected. On March 19 of last year, a supervisor at a train crew depot allowed a train operator to conduct a self-administered alcohol test instead of performing the test directly before allowing operation. Later, a safety inspector from the headquarters' Citizen Safety Office boarded the train at Bucheon Station on Seoul Subway Line 1, noticed a strong smell of alcohol in the driver's cab, but left the scene without taking an immediate alcohol measurement or reporting it to investigative authorities. The internal investigation was conducted 160 minutes after the initial detection, making it impossible to accurately determine the blood alcohol concentration. It was found that the operator drove the train for 184 minutes from Dongincheon Station to Guro Station on the same morning in a suspected state of intoxication.
The railway accident reporting system was also in disarray. There were 65 major railway accidents in the three years from 2022 to 2024, but during the same period, only three railway traffic casualty accidents were reported to the Ministry by railway operators. The Board of Audit and Inspection found that 12 railway operators, including Korea Railroad Corporation, had omitted a total of 258 accident reports. Specifically, there were 37 cases of passengers falling from platforms, 88 cases of being caught in doors, and 133 cases of falls inside trains. Despite this, the Ministry failed to detect these omissions during regular or ad-hoc inspections.
After inspecting 28 stations where platform gap accidents occurred, the Board of Audit and Inspection revealed that at 570 locations operated by Seoul Metro, Busan Transportation Corporation, and Korea Railroad Corporation, the gap between trains and platforms exceeded 10 cm, yet preventative equipment such as safety platforms was insufficient. The Board requested that the Ministry impose fines for unreported accidents and draw up measures to prevent recurrence, as well as devise safety plans for sections where platform gaps are wide or safety equipment is lacking.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
The Board of Audit and Inspection stated, "The safety management system failed to function properly across the construction, operation, and supervision of railways," and added, "We will hold those responsible accountable, and require relevant agencies to implement improvements in areas where institutional reforms are needed."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.