Negative Assessment of Young Poong-MBK Proposal
"Concerns Over Management Instability"

Ahead of Korea Zinc’s annual general shareholders’ meeting, Korea ESG Research Institute, an advisory agency on voting rights, has recommended supporting the current management.

Korea Zinc CI.

Korea Zinc CI.

View original image

On March 9, Korea Zinc announced that Korea ESG Research Institute, in its recently released "2026 Korea Zinc Annual General Meeting Agenda Analysis Report," advised shareholders to exercise their voting rights in support of the current management.


In the report, Korea ESG Research Institute stated, "It is questionable whether the management style of MBK, a private equity fund, would benefit Korea Zinc, which already has strong business performance and a robust financial structure," adding, "For mid- to long-term growth and enhancement of corporate value, it is advisable to maintain the current management system."


The institute also said it has a positive view regarding the achievements, governance improvements, and increased shareholder return under the current management, explaining, "Korea Zinc recorded its highest management performance since its founding in 2025 and has continuously increased shareholder value through governance improvements, cancellation of treasury shares, and expanded cash dividends."


The report also highlighted Korea Zinc’s competitiveness. Korea ESG Research Institute noted, "In various aspects such as business performance, shareholder return policies, and ESG ratings, Korea Zinc demonstrates superiority over Young Poong," and stated, "While MBK’s management approach may be effective for turning around distressed companies, it is questionable whether it is suitable for Korea Zinc, which already enjoys stable performance and a solid financial structure."


The core agenda items for this annual general meeting are the expansion of separately elected audit committee members and the appointment of directors. Korea ESG Research Institute assessed that "Korea Zinc’s proposal to appoint five directors is a more faithful approach to the legislative intent of the amended Commercial Act."


According to the report, the terms of six directors will expire at this year’s annual general meeting. Korea Zinc plans to appoint five of these directors at the upcoming meeting, while the remaining one seat will be filled through a separate audit committee member election process in accordance with the amended Commercial Act, which is effective until September of this year.


Korea ESG Research Institute commented that "Korea Zinc’s proposal to appoint five directors proactively reflects the intent of the Commercial Act amendment," analyzing that "if the audit committee member election is conducted as a separate agenda item, minority shareholders will be able to focus more on reviewing the qualifications and expertise of audit committee candidates."


In contrast, the institute expressed a skeptical stance toward the Young Poong-MBK alliance’s proposed amendment to the articles of incorporation. Regarding the proposal to introduce an executive officer system, the institute explained, "This matter was rejected at the January 2025 extraordinary shareholders’ meeting, with Young Poong-MBK themselves voting against it," and added, "Unless there is a special strategic purpose, it is institutionally more stable to maintain the traditional board structure."


The institute also expressed a negative opinion on the shareholder proposal to specify directors’ duty of care in the articles of incorporation, specifically in relation to new share issuance. Korea ESG Research Institute assessed, "The proposal seeks to set separate standards in the articles of incorporation only for new share issuance, beyond the general duty of care for directors," and explained, "Since a legal judgment has already determined that the new share issuance related to the Crucible Project did not violate the directors’ duty of loyalty or care, there is little need to further codify this in the articles of incorporation."


The institute also voiced concern about the agenda item proposing that the chair of the board, rather than the CEO, preside over the general shareholders’ meeting. Korea ESG Research Institute stated, "Changing the chair of the shareholders’ meeting amid the ongoing management rights dispute at Korea Zinc could heighten management instability," and added, "While appointing the outside director who chairs the board as the chair of the shareholders’ meeting could be considered once management rights have stabilized in the future, at this point, the potential adverse effects are significant."



A Korea Zinc representative said, "It appears that a positive opinion was given based on a comprehensive evaluation of our record performance since the company’s founding, governance improvements, and efforts to increase shareholder returns," adding, "We will do our utmost to block Young Poong-MBK’s hostile takeover attempt, secure management stability, and pursue long-term growth and enhancement of shareholder value."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing