Results of the Government Joint Special Audit of NACF

Fourteen Major Violations Referred for Investigation

NACF Reform Measures to Be Announced Soon

Kang Ho-dong, Chairman of NongHyup Central Union, distributed a total of approximately 490 million won in gifts and return presents, using NongHyup Foundation project funds through key executives of the foundation during 2024–2025. These gifts were given to cooperative presidents, members, and employees who assisted in his election as Chairman. Chairman Kang also received a 10-don gold key (worth about 5.8 million won) from the Regional Cooperative Operation Committee to mark the first anniversary of his inauguration, but later decided to return it.


On March 9, the government announced the results of a special audit of NongHyup Central Union, its subsidiaries, and member cooperatives, which included these findings. To eradicate corruption within NongHyup and strengthen transparency, the government formed a 'Joint Government Special Audit Team' with the Office for Government Policy Coordination, the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs, the Financial Services Commission, the Financial Supervisory Service, the Board of Audit and Inspection, public institutions, and external experts, and conducted a special audit starting on January 26 of this year.


Kang Ho-dong, Chairman of NongHyup Central Union, is delivering a public apology statement at the NongHyup Central Union headquarters on January 13. Photo by Joo Sangdon

Kang Ho-dong, Chairman of NongHyup Central Union, is delivering a public apology statement at the NongHyup Central Union headquarters on January 13. Photo by Joo Sangdon

View original image

This audit was a follow-up to a prior audit conducted by the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs from November 24 to December 19, 2025, and examined overall management practices at NongHyup Central Union and its subsidiaries. The audit also investigated 38 items that required further clarification from the previous review and 12 member cooperatives selected based on anonymous reports.


A government official stated, "This audit identified widespread illegal acts, abuses of authority, preferential loans and contracts, and excessive budget execution by key NongHyup executives. We found that these issues are closely linked to ineffective internal controls and an election system vulnerable to bribery." The official added, "The government plans to refer 14 cases of potential criminal misconduct, such as the private use of public funds and preferential loans, for investigation, and to enact institutional improvements for a provisional total of 96 identified issues to ensure corrective actions are taken."


◆ Rampant Use of Money in Chairman Elections ◆ According to the audit findings, Executive A of NongHyup Foundation embezzled foundation project funds—including promotional rice noodle purchase expenses—and spent 490 million won on return gifts and golf tournament sponsorships for cooperative presidents, members, and employees who assisted in Chairman Kang's election. Department B of the Central Union purchased commemorative gifts such as red ginseng and cosmetics totaling 240 million won, which were delivered to the Chairman's and Vice Chairman's offices.


In February last year, the Regional Cooperative Operation Committee in Region C gave Chairman Kang a 10-don gold key (worth about 5.8 million won) to mark his first year in office. Chairman Kang returned it after a significant amount of time had passed. The government has determined that Chairman Kang violated the Improper Solicitation and Graft Act and has referred the case for investigation.


A government official emphasized, "Another key executive of the Central Union is suspected of significantly increasing advertising expenses at a newspaper company to cover up reports related to election misconduct involving the current Chairman. The government plans to refer six more cases of serious legal violations related to the Chairman for investigation."


◆ Performance Bonuses Paid Without Objective Evaluation ◆ Arbitrary management was also uncovered. Last year, although the boards of the Central Union and Economic Holdings resolved to transfer the Smart Agriculture Local Team of Economic Holdings to the Central Union, the Chairman did not implement this decision. In addition, so-called direct bonuses totaling 7.5 billion won were indiscriminately given to certain member cooperatives and departments over the past five years, without objective performance evaluations, as a form of goodwill payment.


Excessive preferential treatment was also confirmed as a result of the audit. The Chairman and executives of the Central Union received retirement bonuses (severance pay) at least three times higher than those of other cooperatives. They were also provided with official residences that were larger and more expensive than the standard. The previous Chairman received 320 million won as severance pay, and the current Chairman signed a lease for an official residence measuring 84.98 square meters, exceeding the standard size of 60 square meters. The maximum allowed lease deposit was 500 million won, but the Chairman used a residence with a deposit of 1.2 billion won, exceeding the limit by 700 million won.


There were also cases of preferential loans and investments. The Central Union granted large, inappropriate credit loans at the request of NongHyup Economic Holdings, and made substantial loans to companies where retired executives had been reemployed. In 2022, the Central Union inappropriately issued a 14.5 billion won credit loan to a newly established frozen food manufacturing company, which resulted in bad debt (delinquency) from February last year. In addition, since 2011, subsidiary D has allowed a for-profit corporation funded by a NongHyup retirees’ association to use NongHyup buildings rent-free, causing an estimated 3.7 billion won in losses over 15 years.


◆ Sharing Gold Keys and Overseas Trips with Family ◆ Cases of lax budget and asset management were also found. Cooperative presidents and executives received various allowances, gifts, commemorative items, and condolence payments. Executives of the Central Union and its subsidiaries also received gold keys and farewell payments upon retirement, with budgets being allocated in a way that enabled such practices. The government plans to require voluntary withholding and payment of taxes for retirement and other income—such as gold keys and high-value gifts—if income tax was not withheld in accordance with the Income Tax Act.


Extravagant overseas trips were also rampant. One subsidiary supported overseas training for cooperative presidents and others in 2024 whose work was not closely related, at a cost of about 10 million won per person. There were also cases where cooperative presidents and executives traveled overseas with their spouses, and where a supposedly educational trip to Jeju Island lasted three days, but the actual study tour was only two hours, indicating the trip was largely for leisure. There were also cases of corruption or mismanagement in member cooperatives, such as arbitrarily adjusting delinquent loan interest rates, under-provisioning for bad debts, concealing poor financial conditions through fraudulent accounting, and paying out dividends totaling 440 million won, which further undermined the financial soundness of the cooperatives.


Internal controls did not function properly. The compliance officer and audit committee were composed primarily of NongHyup insiders, which limited effective oversight of key executive misconduct, abuse of authority, preferential loans and contracts, and excessive budget management.



The Joint Government Special Audit Team plans to refer 14 cases of serious legal violations—including embezzlement of public funds, preferential loans and contracts, and fraudulent accounting—for investigation. Additionally, NongHyup will be ordered to take corrective action and prepare improvement plans for 96 identified issues. In particular, the government plans to develop fundamental reform measures for NongHyup through this special audit and discussions with the 'NongHyup Reform Task Force', and to announce them as soon as possible.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing