E-Land Retail Covered the Entire Salary of CEO Who Served Concurrently with E-Land World

Fair Trade Commission Imposed 4.1 Billion Won Fine for "Unfair Personnel Support"

Supreme Court: "Fair Trade Commission Failed to Provide Sufficient Evi

Even if a company bears the full salary of an executive who concurrently serves as the CEO of an affiliate, the Supreme Court has ruled that the Fair Trade Commission cannot sanction this as an "unfair provision of human resources" under the Monopoly Regulation and Fair Trade Act unless the Commission specifically asserts and proves that the company made the executive provide labor or other work to the affiliate.

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

Supreme Court, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

View original image

According to the legal community on March 9, the Supreme Court (Presiding Justice Eom Sangpil) upheld the lower court's ruling that ordered the cancellation of a significant portion of the Fair Trade Commission's corrective order in the final appeal filed by E-Land Retail and E-Land World against the Commission.


This case arose in the course of a liquidity crisis faced by E-Land World, the de facto holding company of E-Land Group. The Fair Trade Commission had previously imposed a fine of approximately 4.1 billion won, claiming that E-Land Retail had unfairly supported E-Land World.


The Fair Trade Commission identified three problematic actions: ▲ In 2016, E-Land Retail agreed to purchase real estate from E-Land World and paid a 56 billion won deposit, but canceled the contract and received the deposit back six months later (interest-free loan of funds); ▲ In 2014, E-Land Retail transferred assets related to the clothing brand SPAO to E-Land World and delayed the collection of the 51.1 billion won transfer payment without receiving any delay interest; ▲ From November 2013 to March 2016, E-Land Retail fully covered the salary of former CEO Kim Yeonbae, who concurrently served as CEO of both companies (unfair provision of human resources).


However, the Seoul High Court, which handled the first instance of the Fair Trade Commission's case, found the Commission's actions excessive. The court recognized only part of the SPAO payment delay without interest as unfair support, and ruled that neither the return of the real estate contract deposit nor the payment of personnel expenses for former CEO Kim constituted unfair provision of benefits. Accordingly, the court ruled partially in favor of the plaintiffs and ordered the cancellation of 1.21 billion won out of the total fine of 4.08 billion won.


The Supreme Court also found the lower court's judgment to be correct and dismissed appeals from both parties. The panel stated, "For an 'unfair provision of human resources' as prohibited by the Monopoly Regulation and Fair Trade Act to be recognized, it must be established that the supporting party (E-Land Retail) made the personnel in question provide labor or other work to the recipient entity (E-Land World)."


The court further emphasized, "The Fair Trade Commission, as the authority imposing the disposition, must clearly assert and prove that the amount of salary provided by the recipient entity (E-Land World) is significantly less than the total amount of salary received by the personnel from both sides, as compensation for their work." Thus, the burden of proof lies with the Fair Trade Commission.



The panel concluded, "Based on the evidence submitted by the Fair Trade Commission, it is difficult to find that E-Land Retail made former CEO Kim provide labor or other work to E-Land World," and held that the lower court did not misunderstand the law in canceling the fine.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing