[Economy Pulse] Dizzying Stock Market: Time to Emphasize 'Risk Management' Over 'Returns'
When the Short-Term Rate-of-Return Game Prevails, Corporate Analysis Falls by the Wayside
We Desperately Need the Wisdom of Risk Management, Not the Illusion of Overnight Riches
In recent months, the stock market has experienced a dizzying upward surge. However, this rapid rally abruptly shifted to a period of extreme volatility, triggered by the unexpected geopolitical variable of war between the United States and Iran. As of the closing price on March 6, the KOSPI index remains approximately 70% higher compared to six months ago, and during this period, the price-earnings ratio (PER) soared from 15 to 21. Notably, the decline in the Korean stock market during this downturn was particularly steep. This can be attributed to the combination of a sharp short-term rise and abundant liquidity, which led foreign investors to carry out large-scale asset sales in response to external shocks.
What is even more concerning is that many individual investors continue to maintain excessive optimism about the market. While the outbreak of war between the United States and Iran served as a trigger for the correction, warning signals regarding a potential bubble in the artificial intelligence (AI) sector and excessive expectations were already sounding in global financial markets. It is a sobering moment for reflection: Was the recent surge and subsequent volatility driven not by sober analysis of corporate fundamentals and profitability outlooks, but rather by simple herd behavior and momentum chasing?
This semester, for the first time in my "Financial Economics" class, I introduced a simulated investment exercise for students and was confronted by a shocking reality. It is all too common for simulated investment competitions or evaluations for university students to be based solely on a single indicator: returns. These competitions, usually held over a brief period of one to two weeks, rank participants by who earns the highest returns, which creates a structural contradiction where students who take the most speculative and risky bets and happen to hit the jackpot are deemed the most skilled. In response, I have completely redesigned the exercise model in my course to assess both returns and volatility in parallel.
The essence of stock investing lies in rational expectations regarding a company's intrinsic value and future cash flow. If investors become fixated on short-term return games, company analysis is pushed aside in favor of purely technical trading. We are all too quick to forget the painful lessons of the past. Do you remember the bubble frenzy of the early 2000s, when the KOSDAQ index was close to 3,000 points by today’s standards? After the KOSPI broke through 1,000 points in 1989 and subsequently collapsed, no one could have foreseen that it would take nearly 30 years to regain that level in real value terms. Bubbles born of herd behavior leave behind unimaginable pain when they burst.
Several factors have combined to fuel the recent rapid rise of the Korean stock market. The AI boom has driven a surge in semiconductor demand, sharply raising expectations for improved profitability at Samsung Electronics, SK hynix, and related players in the value chain, which together account for nearly 40% of KOSPI’s market capitalization. In addition, a series of amendments to the Commercial Act have strengthened board responsibilities and regulations regarding treasury shares, fueling hopes of resolving what is known as the “Korea discount.” The government-led corporate value-up program has also contributed to a favorable investment sentiment.
However, the real issue that warrants caution is the “sustainability” of this rally. When share prices are built up solely on supply-demand dynamics and expectations, without being backed by fundamentals, they are nothing but a house of cards. Blind momentum chasing is easily shaken by minor external shocks, often spiraling into panic selling driven by fear. We must be wary of a vicious cycle in which investors who suffer massive losses exit the market, eroding the demand base and leading to prolonged stagnation. In a healthy stock market, it is ultimately actual corporate results and intrinsic value that outweigh short-term supply-demand dynamics.
What we desperately need right now is not the illusion of windfall gains, but the wisdom of risk management. Investors who have diversified by incorporating risk-free assets and other alternatives that can respond to market volatility are not easily swept up by emotional trading, even amid wild market swings. Last week’s extreme roller-coaster market should serve as a lesson, making it a crucial time to coolly reassess and rebalance one’s asset portfolio. The top priority is to lower one’s target returns. The very process of contemplating how to allocate assets, how much to invest in low-volatility stocks, or how to establish hedging measures against a potential market downturn is, in itself, sound investing. Long-term investing is a virtue, but simply leaving one’s portfolio unattended is not the answer. Constantly monitoring market trends, reevaluating assets, and dynamically rebalancing portfolios to reflect new information and changing variables is essential.
The role of policymakers must also be redefined with a clear-eyed perspective. They should not set specific stock index levels as policy targets, nor should they send the market a mistaken signal that the government will artificially prop up share prices. The advancement of financial markets depends not on the absolute level of the index, but on the proper functioning of market discipline. Marginal companies that have lost their growth engines should be allowed to exit naturally, making way for innovative companies in a healthy capital market cycle. It is extremely dangerous to encourage demand by simply asserting that “the Korean market is undervalued and must rise” without any objective assessment of fundamentals.
For the Korean stock market to truly transform into an attractive and healthy investment destination, it must develop resilience—the ability to absorb and recover from unexpected external shocks. Rallies that lack substance are illusory, and steep declines inevitably await at their end. Ultimately, the key to all these issues lies in whether our companies can demonstrate the ability to generate sustainable profits through painful self-driven innovation. We must not forget that the best and most important thing the government can do for the capital market is not to boost stock prices, but to create a fertile environment where companies can freely develop new technologies and pursue innovation.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Nohsun Kwak, Professor of Economics at Sogang University (Former President of the Korean Finance Association)
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.