More Negotiation Channels, but Third Unions Pushed Aside

Song Siyoung: "Established Unions Will Monopolize Negotiation Rights"

Despite Calls to "Relax Negotiation Unit Separation Requirements"

Burden of Increased Negotiation Costs, Lack of Consensus Remain Issues

With the implementation of the so-called “Yellow Envelope Act” (an amendment to Articles 2 and 3 of the Trade Union and Labor Relations Adjustment Act) that expands the scope of negotiation parties fast approaching, minority labor unions, often referred to as “Millennials & Gen Z unions,” are expressing concerns. They worry that as numerous subcontractor unions gain the ability to negotiate directly with the primary contractor, the already limited presence of minority unions could become even more marginalized.

Millennials & Gen Z Unions Losing Ground Ahead of "Yellow Envelope Act" Implementation View original image

According to the labor sector on March 9, there is growing concern among Millennials & Gen Z unions that the implementation of the Yellow Envelope Act on March 10 will further entrench the practice of labor-management agreements dominated by the two major union federations: the Korean Confederation of Trade Unions and the Federation of Korean Trade Unions. Song Siyoung, Emergency Committee Chair of the Saerogochim Workers' Council, argued, “Powerful, established unions with massive organizational capacity will monopolize negotiation rights,” adding, “A third union will most likely be excluded from the negotiation process.”


Millennials & Gen Z unions refer to labor unions that have emerged with a “non-ideological, pragmatic” approach, mainly composed of workers in their 20s to 40s. Notable examples include the Seoul Metro Right Labor Union, LG Electronics People-Oriented Office Workers’ Union, and Kumho Tire Office Workers’ Union. The Saerogochim Workers' Council acts as a coalition of such unions. They use the term “council” instead of “federation” (as used by the two major union federations) to reflect their operation as a consultative body rather than a hierarchical organization. Millennials & Gen Z unions have drawn attention as a “third force,” raising white-collar issues such as expanding remote work and improving the comprehensive wage system, which have often been sidelined in labor discussions.


However, in recent times, Millennials & Gen Z unions have struggled to expand their influence, remaining marginalized within the negotiation structure. Under current law, minority unions with less than a majority of union members are not subject to “mandatory negotiation,” which is seen as a limiting factor. Unless they participate in a joint negotiation delegation or are recognized as a separate negotiation unit, it is difficult for them to enter direct negotiations. As a result, negotiation leadership has been formed mainly around the two major union federations.


Minority unions are concerned that the Yellow Envelope Act could become an additional burden under these circumstances. According to the Yellow Envelope Act and the primary contractor-subcontractor negotiation procedure manual prepared by the Ministry of Employment and Labor, a subcontractor union can demand direct negotiation with the primary contractor without any coordination process with the primary contractor's union. If the characteristics of the work or working conditions are significantly different, negotiation units among subcontractor unions can also be separated.


From the perspective of Millennials & Gen Z unions, the increase in negotiation channels between primary contractors and subcontractors means that issues and time will be further divided, potentially narrowing their space even more. An executive from a public corporation’s Millennials & Gen Z union stated, “Due to the limitations of the existing negotiation structure, there are workplaces where Millennials & Gen Z unions exist in name only, with their activities virtually dissolved,” expressing concern that, “Once the Yellow Envelope Act is implemented, minority unions within primary contractors may face even more difficult circumstances than subcontractor unions.”

Millennials & Gen Z Unions Losing Ground Ahead of "Yellow Envelope Act" Implementation View original image

Some have suggested that “relaxing the requirements for separating negotiation units” could be a solution. Kim Han-yeop, Chairperson of the Kumho Tire Office Workers’ Union, who has expressed support for the Yellow Envelope Act, pointed out, “There are clear limits to having a majority union represent the unique difficulties of office workers, so expanding recognition of negotiation unit separation is necessary.” He emphasized the need for flexibility in separating negotiation units even within primary contractor unions when job categories and roles are distinctly different.


However, there are also views that institutional reform will not be easy. Lee Byounghoon, Professor Emeritus of Sociology at Chung-Ang University, stated, “While I understand the difficulties faced by minority unions, including Millennials & Gen Z unions, excessive segmentation of negotiation units would significantly increase the employer’s negotiation costs, likely provoking strong opposition from the business sector.” He advised, “Since there is not yet sufficient social consensus on system reform, it would be necessary to apply for negotiation unit separation with the Labor Relations Commission on a case-by-case basis.”



Meanwhile, the two major union federations are expected to launch a large-scale “spring labor offensive” to expand their negotiation power in light of the new law. Jeon Hoil, spokesperson for the Korean Confederation of Trade Unions, said, “Negotiation procedures remain complicated and subcontracted workers’ negotiation rights are still limited,” and vowed, “We will continue to fight until we achieve substantive negotiations with primary contractors and institutional improvements.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing