The Recurring "Lottery Admissions" Dilemma
Strategy Over Effort, Questions of Fairness

[Reporter’s Notebook] Admitted to Seoul National University with Level 5 in English... The Unpredictable CSAT View original image

"Did someone really get into Seoul National University regular admissions with an English grade of 5?"


At the end of February 2026, as the college admissions cycle was wrapping up, a photo posted by a test taker certifying their acceptance into the Department of Mathematical Sciences at Seoul National University sent shockwaves through college entrance exam communities. The score report, released along with the acceptance letter, showed an English grade of 5 and a Chemistry II grade of 4. Since the College Scholastic Ability Test (CSAT) is often decided by just a single point, many wondered how it was possible to be accepted to Seoul National University with an English grade of 5. While Seoul National University responded that it was "difficult to verify," admissions experts agreed that "it is possible."



The first answer lies in Seoul National University's English score deduction system. At Seoul National University, points are deducted according to English grade. For an English grade of 5, a total of 6 points are subtracted. However, this difference can be made up with just one math question or a few high-difficulty Korean language questions. In particular, Seoul National University reflects mathematics at a rate of 40%, and the student in question had a perfect standardized math score (139 points).


This year's CSAT conditions also played a role. In the 2026 CSAT, the percentage of test takers receiving an English grade of 1 dropped from 6.22% the previous year to 3.11%. As the English section became more difficult, universities like Seoul National University, where English has a low weighting, saw Korean and math scores become even more decisive in admissions outcomes. Admissions experts analyzing this situation commented as follows.

Yonhap News

Yonhap News

View original image

"The student must have studied very hard, but was also very lucky."


This kind of "admissions upset" is not unprecedented. In the 2019 admissions cycle, a student with a math grade of 4 was accepted to medical school, as their exceptionally high Korean language score—during a year dubbed "Hellish Korean"—offset the lower math grade. In 2018, a student with an English grade of 4 was admitted to the Department of Nuclear Engineering at Seoul National University. In 2023, a student with a Korean grade of 5 passed the first round of regular admissions for the Department of Physics and Astronomy at Seoul National University.


Such unexpected outcomes offer hope. However, the frequency of these upsets also suggests that the admissions system is unstable. With fluctuating levels of test difficulty—swinging between "easy CSAT" and "hard CSAT"—constantly changing education policies, and ever more complex admissions procedures, it is difficult for students to strategize and prepare in advance.


As a result, students become increasingly reliant on private consulting for admissions strategies, and outcomes often come down to luck. One education expert noted, "This shows just how unstable the CSAT, which we believe to be a fair exam, really is."


What if the 2027 CSAT features an "easy English" section? Would it be possible to expect the same outcome with an English grade of 5? The comment that "the student was lucky" arises from this very background. As the 2028 CSAT moves to an integrated social studies and science system, what new variables and upsets might occur?



The moment admissions outcomes are explained by "good luck or bad luck" rather than the result of effort, faith in the CSAT as a fair exam may begin to falter.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing