Democratic Party Considers Citizens’ Nomination Jury for Integrated Special Mayor Primary
Candidates Narrowed from 8 to 5 After Joint Speeches and Debates

Hyungbae Min, Youngrok Kim Take Cautious Stance...
Gijung Kang, Junghoon Shin Offer

Major Candidates for the Democratic Party Primary Election for the Integrated Special Mayor of Jeonnam and Gwangju. Top row from left: Gwangju Mayor Ki-jeong Kang, Jeonnam Governor Young-rok Kim, Assemblymen Hyung-bae Min and Jeong-hoon Shin. Bottom row from left: Assemblymen Gaeho Lee, Byung-hoon Lee, Junho Jung, and Cheolhyun Joo.

Major Candidates for the Democratic Party Primary Election for the Integrated Special Mayor of Jeonnam and Gwangju. Top row from left: Gwangju Mayor Ki-jeong Kang, Jeonnam Governor Young-rok Kim, Assemblymen Hyung-bae Min and Jeong-hoon Shin. Bottom row from left: Assemblymen Gaeho Lee, Byung-hoon Lee, Junho Jung, and Cheolhyun Joo.

View original image

The Democratic Party of Korea is working to introduce a Citizens’ Nomination Jury System in the process of selecting a candidate for the integrated Jeonnam-Gwangju Special Mayor in the June 3 local elections, drawing attention to how the primary election method may affect the outcome. As this is the first election for a local government head since the administrative integration of Gwangju and Jeonnam, political circles analyze that the rules of the primary itself now carry political significance.


With the Democratic Party’s Public Office Candidate Recommendation Management Committee proposing the use of the Citizens’ Nomination Jury System in the Jeonnam-Gwangju special mayoral primary, candidates are expressing both hope and concern.


The Citizens’ Nomination Jury System involves a panel of ordinary citizens and experts who participate in candidate debates and evaluations, with the results of their voting reflected in the candidate selection. The Democratic Party introduced this system ahead of the 2010 local elections to address criticism that primaries centered on opinion polls and party member votes devolved into contests of organizational strength.


Democratic Party Nomination Committee: "Proposing a Primary Method That Reflects the Spirit of Integration"

According to The Asia Business Daily’s coverage on March 4, the Democratic Party confirmed all applicants as primary candidates for the mayor of Seoul, governor of Gyeonggi, mayor of Ulsan, and the integrated Jeonnam-Gwangju special mayor, ahead of the June 3 local elections, on March 2.

Kim Isu, Chair of the Central Party Nomination Committee of the Democratic Party of Korea, is announcing the results of the candidate screening at the central party office in Yeouido, Seoul, on the 2nd. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

Kim Isu, Chair of the Central Party Nomination Committee of the Democratic Party of Korea, is announcing the results of the candidate screening at the central party office in Yeouido, Seoul, on the 2nd. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

Kim Isu, Chairman of the Democratic Party's Central Nomination Management Committee, announced the results of the nomination review at the party headquarters in Yeouido, Seoul, on this day, stating, "For the integrated Jeonnam-Gwangju Special City, we selected all applicants for Gwangju mayor and Jeonnam governor as primary candidates."


Accordingly, eight people are participating in the Jeonnam-Gwangju special mayoral primary: Gijung Kang, Mayor of Gwangju; Youngrok Kim, Governor of Jeonnam; Assemblymen Hyungbae Min, Junghoon Shin, Gaeho Lee, Junho Jeong, and Cheolhyun Joo; and former lawmaker Byunghoon Lee.


The Democratic Party is considering narrowing down the candidates to the top five through joint speeches and debates, and then utilizing the Citizens’ Nomination Jury System in the main primary.


Chairman Kim stated, "For the integrated Jeonnam-Gwangju Special City, we will propose to the Supreme Council the inclusion of a Citizens’ Nomination Jury System primary, in accordance with the party constitution and regulations, as well as the implementation of touring votes, to reflect the spirit of integration at the time of the main primary."


Differences in Candidates’ Views on the Citizens’ Jury and Other Primary Methods

As discussions on the primary method continue, candidates are expressing divergent positions.


Hyungbae Min, a Democratic Party lawmaker who declared his candidacy for the Jeonnam-Gwangju special mayor, adopted a cautious stance on introducing the Citizens’ Nomination Jury System.


Assemblyman Min stated, "It is uncomfortable for a candidate to comment on the rules, so I will not officially announce my position," but added, "I believe it will not stray far from the party’s principles of party member sovereignty, national sovereignty, and one-person-one-vote."


He continued, "There are concerns that the Citizens’ Jury System is susceptible to manipulation, and there have been negative cases in the past," adding, "In the context of administrative integration, careful consideration is needed regarding the composition and operation of the jury."

On the morning of January 2nd, key figures from Gwangju and Jeonnam gathered in front of the Democracy Gate at the National May 18th Democratic Cemetery in Buk-gu, Gwangju, holding hands for a commemorative photo. Photo by Bo-hyun Song

On the morning of January 2nd, key figures from Gwangju and Jeonnam gathered in front of the Democracy Gate at the National May 18th Democratic Cemetery in Buk-gu, Gwangju, holding hands for a commemorative photo. Photo by Bo-hyun Song

View original image

Youngrok Kim, Governor of Jeonnam, expressed a negative view on the method of narrowing down candidates to the top five in the preliminary primary.


Governor Kim said, "If three candidates come from one region and two from another, it could be structurally disadvantageous," and added, "A four-person primary would be more reasonable."


However, regarding the Citizens’ Nomination Jury System, he said, "I respect the party’s decision as it allows for the opinions of city and provincial residents to be reflected," and emphasized, "Above all, it is important that the opinions of city and provincial residents are properly reflected in the primary process."


In contrast, some candidates, such as Gijung Kang, Mayor of Gwangju, and Assemblyman Junghoon Shin, expressed positive views on the introduction of the Citizens’ Nomination Jury System.


Mayor Kang wrote on Facebook, "As soon as the Special Integration Act was passed, the method for selecting the integrated mayor was announced," adding, "Narrowing the eight preliminary candidates down to five and selecting the special mayor through the Citizens’ Nomination Jury System can reflect the spirit of integration."


He said, "The advantage is that citizens and provincial residents can organically come together to assess candidates’ abilities and vision to lead the integrated special city, going beyond simple opinion polling," and added, "There is no perfect method for candidate selection, but in the current phase of integration, this seems to be an appropriate approach."


Assemblyman Shin stated, "Setting up regional democratic selection criteria and processes for candidates is a positive step," and added, "It is meaningful in that it expands citizens’ choices by thoroughly verifying candidates’ qualifications and abilities, rather than simply holding a popularity contest."


The 2010 Gwangju Primary Debate... Pros and Cons of the Citizens’ Nomination Jury

The renewed spotlight on the Citizens’ Nomination Jury System stems from a past primary in Gwangju where it was actually implemented.


In the 2010 Gwangju mayoral primary, a combined approach was used, with the evaluation of the Citizens’ Jury and an all-party-member poll. In the jury evaluation, Assemblyman Yongseop Lee ranked first with 41.6%, former Minister Dongchae Chung ranked second with 29.5%, and Assemblyman Woon-tae Kang ranked third with 28.9%.


However, in the all-party-member poll, Assemblyman Woon-tae Kang ranked first with 46.7%, reversing the average vote ranking and securing the final nomination. Assemblyman Kang won with a final vote share of 37.8%, just 0.45 percentage points ahead of Assemblyman Yongseop Lee, who received 37.35%.


During this process, some candidates raised issues regarding the polling process, leading to legal responses and calls for investigations, which sparked controversy. Although the Democratic Party’s Central Reconsideration Committee rejected the request for a review and upheld the primary results, the situation left significant aftereffects in the local political scene.


In the 2022 local elections, the Citizens’ Jury method was used in some basic-level primaries in the capital region, employing a mixed model that combined 40% on-site and expert evaluation panels, 30% general citizens, and 30% dues-paying party members.

On January 9th, during a luncheon meeting presided over by President Lee Jae-myung at the Blue House, attendees took a commemorative photo following discussions on the administrative integration of Gwangju and Jeonnam. Provided by Gwangju City

On January 9th, during a luncheon meeting presided over by President Lee Jae-myung at the Blue House, attendees took a commemorative photo following discussions on the administrative integration of Gwangju and Jeonnam. Provided by Gwangju City

View original image

A political insider commented, "Since this is the first local government head election after the Gwangju-Jeonnam integration, the primary method itself has acquired political meaning," and added, "If the Citizens’ Jury System is actually introduced, it could become a variable in the competitive dynamics between candidates."



Seungyong Oh, Director at MetaVoice, said, "Aside from the jury system, there are few practical deliberative procedures for vetting candidates suitable for the integrated special mayoral election," but also emphasized, "It is important to maintain security to prevent manipulation in the jury selection process and organizational mobilization."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing