Breakdown in Cooperation Between the Ministry of Land and Local Governments

[Reporter’s Notebook] “Not Even Answering Calls”: Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport Leaves Field in Confusion View original image

"The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport isn’t answering calls these days."


An official in charge of land transaction permits at a district office in Seoul made this complaint during a recent phone call with a reporter. Since the government announced its supplementary measures to defer the mandatory real residence requirement on February 12, a flood of complaints from multiple homeowners has poured into district offices, but the relevant ministry has not been answering calls from the local governments. Another district official stated, "Since the Ministry’s responsible department doesn’t pick up, we’re forced to use personal connections to get information from acquaintances in the ministry."


The ministry’s lack of communication has come under the spotlight because of confusion caused by the phrase “initial contract expiration date” included in a press release issued by the government last month. In the release, the government stated, “The mandatory residence requirement will be deferred until the expiration date of the initial lease contract signed as of the amendment announcement date.” The Ministry explained that this means “the expiration date of currently signed contracts,” but in the real estate field, “initial” is commonly understood as being distinct from “renewal.” For tenants exercising their right to renew the contract, the “current contract” is a renewal, not the “initial contract.” Therefore, it was a natural interpretation for front-line district officials, who are well-versed in legal terminology, to question whether renewed contracts were excluded from the policy.


With the definition of terms left unclear, and as the sensitive issue of deferring the real residence requirement was being addressed, inquiries from residents wanting to confirm their eligibility surged. An official at Songpa District Office said, “We made several inquiries to the Ministry due to the flood of complaints, but couldn’t get through until March 3, when we finally received confirmation that the residence requirement is also deferred for existing renewal contracts.”


In particular, at a training session for local governments regarding the supplementary measures held at the LH Seoul Headquarters in Gangnam District on February 25, the Ministry reportedly explained that renewed contracts were not included in the interpretation of “initial contract.” An official who attended from a district office said, “District officials with extensive experience in land transaction permit work repeatedly questioned why existing renewed contracts were excluded, as it didn’t make sense to us,” adding, “But Ministry officials firmly repeated that they were indeed excluded.”


Due to the lack of communication and unsatisfactory guidance from the responsible ministry, each district office has been interpreting the press release differently and responding accordingly. Nowon District guided residents that renewal status did not matter and that the deferral applied, while some other district offices rejected land transaction permit applications, stating, “This is not the initial contract.”



Recently, as more properties owned by multiple homeowners have been put on the market, the rise in real estate prices has slowed down. In order for policy intentions to take root, coordination between the central government and local governments is paramount. The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport should be reminded that the completeness of a policy is not measured by grand announcements, but by issuing detailed guidelines and providing responsible answers so that not a single citizen is left confused at the civil complaint counter.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing