Peter & Kim's Victory Against Elliott
Managing Partner Gapyu Kim

Even if collecting and paying pensions
is a matter of the state,
exercising voting rights with held shares
is an act of a private economic entity

Gapyu Kim, Attorney at Peter & Kim Law Firm

Gapyu Kim, Attorney at Peter & Kim Law Firm

View original image

"The son (National Pension Service) rightfully exercised his voting rights, but if someone keeps filing lawsuits against the father (the government), the son inevitably becomes intimidated. With this victory, an environment has been established where the National Pension Service can invest independently, free from external pressure."


On March 4, in an interview with The Asia Business Daily, Gapyu Kim, Managing Partner at Peter & Kim Law Firm (17th Judicial Research and Training Institute), who led the Korean government's "come-from-behind victory" in the international investment dispute (ISDS) against the US hedge fund Elliott Management, made these remarks. He emphasized, "How can the exercise of shareholder rights be considered an act of state authority? While collecting and paying pensions may be state affairs, exercising voting rights with held shares is a fundamentally reasonable act of a 'private economic entity,' and the UK court accepted this legal principle."


This case began when Elliott claimed to have suffered damages from the National Pension Service's support for the merger between Samsung C&T and Cheil Industries in 2015, and initiated ISDS proceedings in 2018 based on the Korea-US Free Trade Agreement (FTA). In 2023, the arbitral tribunal (PCA) ordered the government to pay approximately 107.82 million US dollars, but the government contested the decision and filed for annulment in the UK court. After overcoming dismissal at the first trial and going through the appeals process, the government recently won in the High Court, preventing a drain on state coffers.


Kim pointed out, "The Korea-US FTA designed the gateway for ISDS to be extremely narrow to prevent unnecessary arbitration. However, the arbitral tribunal interpreted this scope far too broadly." Article 11.1 of the Korea-US FTA limits arbitration to damages caused by measures taken by state institutions, and Kim argued that the PCA's classification of the National Pension Service as a state institution fundamentally contradicts the intent of the agreement.


Responding to some opinions advocating settlement due to concerns over interest payments, Kim said, "Principle is important for a nation. It is not the government's stance to accept an unjust ruling out of fear of a 5% statutory interest rate. If we allow a wrongful precedent, the future waste of national resources and litigation costs will be far greater than the current interest payments."


The issue is not yet entirely resolved. The UK court found that the actions of the Presidential Office and the Ministry of Health and Welfare intervening in the National Pension Service's decision-making process were indeed "relevant measures." Nevertheless, Kim analyzed, "Because the premise that the National Pension Service's exercise of voting rights constitutes an act of the state has been dismantled, it is now much more difficult for the other party to prove causality than before."


The legal community estimates the tangible and intangible value of this victory could reach several trillion won. The National Pension Service, with its powerful domestic equity capital of about 264 trillion won (as of the end of last year), has played the role of a "casting vote" in major corporate control disputes involving companies like Korea Zinc and Hanmi Pharm. In particular, during the KOSPI "super cycle," strengthening shareholder rights is considered a key driver supporting the continued rise of the stock market.



Kim assessed, "With this ruling, the National Pension Service can now raise its voice with greater conviction and actively work toward improving corporate governance and enhancing shareholder value, free from the threat of ISDS challenges from foreign capital."

[Victory Engineered] National Pension Service Overcomes "Elliott Trauma," Paving the Way for Independent Voting View original image


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing