[K-Defense Season 2 Analysis] K-Defense's Success Continues, but Its Fundamentals Remain Weak [Yang Nakkyu's Defence Club]
Building a Solid Foundation for Defense Exports
The Lee Jaemyung administration has made "fostering K-Defense and entering the world’s top four defense powers" a key national agenda. Defense industry experts point out that financial policy must be addressed first to achieve this goal. At the end of February last year, the National Assembly passed an amendment to the Export-Import Bank of Korea Act, increasing the Export-Import Bank’s statutory capital limit from 15 trillion won to 25 trillion won. This was prompted by a 30 trillion won second defense export contract with Poland, which was at risk of collapsing due to hitting the financial support ceiling. The appeals of defense companies were thus accommodated within six months.
However, this was merely a temporary fix. The key regulation limiting credit to any single country to "40% of the bank’s equity capital" remains unchanged. The increase by 10 trillion won also introduces the potential for additional risks. If K-Defense secures another order on the scale of Poland, it will once again have to seek approval from the National Assembly.
The financial support systems of advanced countries are different. K-Shipbuilding is currently vying for Canada’s next-generation submarine project (CPSP). Its competitor, Germany, is offering large-scale financial guarantees under a government-to-government (G2G) transaction model. Notably, Canada recently became the first non-European country to join "SAFE," the European Union’s joint military procurement and defense investment program. Germany is supporting Canada to access approximately 150 billion euros (about 220 trillion won) in military funding loans. Financial support is being wielded as the top priority bargaining tool in negotiations.
Increase in Financial Guarantees Needed for Rising Exports
This is a common policy among advanced countries, not just Germany. In the United States, the Defense Security Cooperation Agency (DSCA) contracts with defense companies on behalf of purchasing countries and guarantees quality and implementation. Through the Foreign Military Financing (FMF) program, it also provides allied nations with grants or low-interest loans for weapons purchases. France operates dedicated export financing for defense through the public investment bank Bpifrance. The 2021 Rafale fighter jet contract with the United Arab Emirates (UAE) was possible thanks to such financial support. The Korean government plans to launch a "Strategic Export Finance Fund" through special legislation in the first half of this year, but experts argue that the process must be expedited.
For "K-Defense" to continue its success, a solid foundation is essential. It is urgent to nurture materials, parts, and equipment (so-called "Sobu-jang") companies, rather than focusing solely on the four major defense corporations. These companies must move beyond their limited roles as subcontractors and build fundamental competitiveness. In fact, the European Union has declared a "Buy European" policy, giving preference to European-made weapons. The trend is shifting from importing finished products toward strengthening domestic production. As demand for parts, technology transfers, and joint development increases, it has become critical to establish export policies for domestic materials, parts, and equipment companies.
Urgent Need for Localization Policies to Foster Defense SMEs
The localization rate for components in K-Defense is estimated at around 65%. Localizing parts is directly linked to exports. If key components are imported, export approval from the country of origin is required, which can result in delays or even refusals when exporting to third countries. For a long time, Hanwha Aerospace’s K-9 self-propelled howitzer relied on German-made engines and transmissions ("power packs"). As a result, without export approval from the German government, even orders secured by Korea could not be fulfilled, putting Korean companies in a state of technological dependency. While there has been a recent breakthrough with the successful localization of the engine, many mainstay weapon systems—such as Hyundai Rotem’s K-2 tank and Korea Aerospace Industries’ (KAI) FA-50—still suffer from the Achilles’ heel of high dependence on foreign components.
Need to Address Technology Fees Hindering Price Competitiveness
Technology fees must also be addressed. The Agency for Defense Development collects a technology fee amounting to 3% of sales revenue whenever technology is transferred and sales are made. However, conflicts persist. ADD explains that collecting technology fees is a rightful claim of the technology owner and that these funds are necessary to motivate researchers and reinvest in technology development. On the other hand, defense companies argue that technology fee exemptions must be extended to maintain export competitiveness; at the very least, the calculation of fees should reflect the extent to which the company has directly contributed to the development of the exported weapons system.
An industry representative stated, "We must not miss the opportunity to join the ranks of top defense nations due to the technology fee debate," adding, "The government and National Assembly must step in to review the technology fee system."
Need to Consolidate Disorganized Exhibitions, Seminars, and Organizations
Defense companies are suffering from the proliferation of uncoordinated defense exhibitions, seminars, and academic conferences. This year, two major ground weapon defense exhibitions—DX KOREA and KADEX 2024—are scheduled to be held in September and October, respectively. During the same period in September, eight key K-Defense importing countries—including Poland, Australia, and the Philippines—will also host their own exhibitions. In October, six other countries, including the United States, UAE, and the Czech Republic, are preparing exhibitions. While participating in overseas exhibitions is more efficient for defense companies, they are often pressured by veterans’ associations and government agencies to reluctantly participate in domestic exhibitions.
The government has also pointed out the inefficiencies caused by the excessive number of defense exhibitions. The Office for Government Policy Coordination once instructed the military to consolidate events when each branch began holding its own exhibition. In 2008, the Army was ordered to merge the biennial Ground Forces Festival with the Air Force’s odd-year "Seoul International Aerospace and Defense Exhibition (Seoul ADEX)" due to the small scale and low participation rates from overseas defense companies. However, this consolidation was reversed with a change in administration.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Won Junhee, President of the Korea Defense Small and Venture Business Association, said, "American companies like Palantir and Anduril have grown because of research and development policies that accept failure," adding, "Seventy percent of core research and development budget packages should be allocated to small and venture businesses."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.