Immediately after passage of the third Commercial Act amendment in the plenary session
KT&G and others announce full retirement of treasury shares
Business community: "Focusing on short-term payouts instead of R&D investment"
Experts: "Ne

The so-called "third amendment to the Commercial Act," which mandates the retirement of treasury shares held by companies, passed the plenary session of the National Assembly on the 25th. While some view it as an appropriate measure to resolve the so-called "Korea Discount," others criticize it as an excessive infringement on corporate management autonomy. In this context, the business community is calling for supplementary legislation to minimize any side effects that may arise in the future.


The core of this amendment is the requirement that companies must retire treasury shares they have acquired within one year. Existing treasury shares already held must be disposed of or retired within a grace period of one year and six months. However, there are exceptions that allow holding and disposing of treasury shares in certain cases: when they are used for employee compensation, for implementing employee stock ownership plans, for comprehensive share exchanges, transfers, and mergers, or when the company stipulates in its articles of incorporation that such holdings are for achieving legitimate business management objectives.

On the 25th, at the 8th plenary session of the February special session of the National Assembly, the third amendment to the Commercial Act is being passed. Yonhap News

On the 25th, at the 8th plenary session of the February special session of the National Assembly, the third amendment to the Commercial Act is being passed. Yonhap News

View original image

Warning of side effects..."Share prices could face a backlash"

Immediately after the bill passed, major listed companies began moving to respond. On the afternoon of the same day, KT&G held a board meeting and resolved to retire all of its existing treasury shares, totaling 10,866,189 shares, which correspond to 9.5% of its total number of issued shares. This is regarded as the first major case in which the intent of the amendment to the Commercial Act was immediately reflected in corporate management following its passage.


However, most large corporations remain concerned that the passage of this amendment will, in effect, shut down the use of treasury shares, which has been one of the core tools for defending management control. In particular, as the so-called "treasury share magic" that strengthens the controlling shareholder's influence during spin-offs becomes impossible, companies pursuing governance restructuring now inevitably have to revise their scenarios.


A senior industry official said, "Whether to retire treasury shares should fall within the realm of optimal management judgment depending on the company's situation, but forcing this by law is an overly mechanical tool," expressing concern. The official added, "There are cases where it is necessary to hold treasury shares to defend management control when needed, and it is clear that such defensive tools will be weakened."


There are also concerns that future-oriented management activities such as mergers and acquisitions (M&A) will be dampened. Another corporate official said, "Treasury shares not only serve as a white knight but are also used for various management activities, such as being sold in the market when necessary to raise funds for M&A," and added, "If retirement is mandated, funds that should be used for research and development (R&D) investment or new businesses will be forcibly injected into one-off value-up retirements, which will have side effects of undermining companies' mid- to long-term competitiveness."

Business Community Fears Loss of "Management Control Shield" Under Mandatory Treasury Share Retirement (Comprehensive) View original image

Regulation without defensive tools..."Supplementary legislation is urgent"

While the business community agrees with the intent of enhancing shareholder returns, it is calling for detailed institutional improvements that do not undermine the dynamism of corporate management. Lee Sangho, Head of the Economic Policy Division at the Federation of Korean Industries, said, "For this amendment to contribute to enhancing shareholder value and advancing the capital market, we hope that issues surrounding treasury shares acquired for specific purposes in the course of M&A and similar transactions will be supplemented through further discussions going forward."


He continued, "Since expanding corporate earnings is crucial for shareholder returns, we hope the National Assembly will also accelerate regulatory reforms aimed at revitalizing business activities," and stressed, "The business community will likewise continue efforts to strengthen communication with shareholders and to enhance market trust."


Academia is also voicing strong concerns about the side effects this amendment may bring. Choi Seungjae, a law professor at Sejong University, analyzed, "Retiring treasury shares could reduce the number of shares and push up share prices, but conversely, the resulting capital reduction could raise the debt ratio and weigh negatively on share prices." In particular, Professor Choi pointed out, "During the IMF program era, Korea lifted most of its management control defense mechanisms to attract foreign capital," and suggested, "If follow-up legislation is discussed, introducing appropriate management control defense tools such as poison pills or Japan-style stock acquisition rights could be considered."


Kwon Jaeyeol, a professor at the Law School of Kyung Hee University, noted, "Since treasury shares have been the only management control defense tool for companies, there is a high possibility that, in order to protect management control, companies will focus solely on short-term profit returns such as improving shareholder relations, rather than on long-term R&D investment."

"A virtuous cycle to enhance corporate value must be established"

In contrast to these concerns, some argue that this amendment should be used as an opportunity to improve corporate fundamentals and redesign capital policies. The advice is that listed companies should view this amendment as a structural turning point toward "shareholder primacy" and respond proactively.



The Corporate Governance Center of Yulchon LLC stated, "It is urgent to categorize existing treasury shares by purpose of use and establish an optimal roadmap for retirement, disposal, and retention," and added, "In particular, where it is necessary to hold shares for business management purposes, companies need a strategy to proactively reflect such exceptions by amending their articles of incorporation at this year's regular general shareholders' meetings." It went on to emphasize, "It is necessary to establish a comprehensive capital allocation policy, including dividend policy and growth investment plans, and to communicate with the market in order to build a virtuous cycle that enhances corporate value."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing