Prosecution once again touts its supplementary investigation results, just like five years ago
Stressing control over the police while avoiding checks on itself
For the police to differ from the prosecution, accountable investigations and oversight

[Reporter’s Notebook] The Courage To Be Checked: A Question Investigative Bodies Must Answer View original image

"Here we go again." A police officer let out a sigh as he read an article about the prosecution's achievements in supplementary investigations. He soon added, "The separation of investigative and indictment powers isn't because the prosecution is incapable of investigating, is it?"


Recently, the prosecution has been issuing a series of press releases highlighting its supplementary investigative achievements. These statements usually point out shortcomings in police investigations and go on to explain how well the prosecution has "improved" them. When the term "complete deprivation of prosecutorial investigative authority" (commonly known as 'Prosecution Reform') first appeared in 2021, the prosecution responded in the same way. The narrative that the abolition of supplementary investigative powers would immediately result in a flood of unfair victims is no different now than it was then.


If you listen to both the police and the prosecution, this conflict dates back to the enactment of the Criminal Procedure Act in 1954. This law defines the investigations conducted by prosecutors and police officers, ending with the phrase "shall investigate" or "must investigate." Investigation is not something that may or may not be done; it is a duty that must be fulfilled. The prosecution's approach of unnecessarily belittling the police in order to justify its own existence lacks persuasiveness.


The core that upholds the duty of investigation is "checks and balances." Because investigative authority, which can restrict citizens' basic rights, carries a high risk of abuse no matter which agency exercises it. In Korea's legal system, the "prosecutor's warrant review principle" was introduced into the Criminal Procedure Act after the 5·16 military coup. The following year, an amendment to the Constitution restricted the right to request warrants to prosecutors. The prosecution controlled the police with exclusive authority, but in doing so, it also became more distant from checks and oversight.


The debate over supplementary investigative powers should not be about whether such powers exist, but rather about how to redesign the structure of responsibility and control over the exercise of investigative powers. If the supplementary investigative powers are to be abolished, it is necessary to prepare for how the Serious Crime Investigation Agency and the police will be kept in check, and how the balance between the Serious Crime Investigation Agency and the National Police Agency will be maintained. If the supplementary investigative powers are retained, their scope and conditions must be strictly limited.


Recently, a junior reporter covered a case in which an elderly man, who was driving a rental car while his vehicle was being repaired, was indicted. The man, a national merit recipient who became disabled due to war injuries, did not know that a new disability permit had to be issued for each vehicle. Although the court acquitted him, the prosecution appealed. During this same period, the prosecution chose not to appeal the Daejang-dong development corruption trial. The prosecution's claim that the police must be kept in check is legitimate. Nevertheless, the reason the political sphere can stoke hardline sentiment for "abolishing the prosecution" is that the prosecution, which belatedly claims to protect human rights, has little credibility for doing so.



Authority gains legitimacy through checks and balances. Before arguing over which powers to secure, investigative agencies should first demonstrate the courage to accept oversight themselves. Without self-discipline, they are doomed only to repeat the history of the prosecution.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing