Regulatory debate accelerates after president's remarks
Only 10% of lease-business loans are apartment-backed... many individuals rely on "gap investment"

As President Lee Jaemyung has repeatedly called for stronger lending regulations on multiple-home owners ahead of the June 3 local elections, financial authorities are grappling with how to respond. As the pattern continues in which the authorities flesh out measures once the president effectively presents guidelines, concerns are growing that the policy direction is being set first without sufficient understanding of actual conditions. Financial authorities are now being asked to come up with measures swiftly, while also designing policies in a sophisticated way that will enhance effectiveness and minimize side effects.


An apartment-dense area viewed from N Seoul Tower on Namsan, Seoul, on the 19th. Yonhap News

An apartment-dense area viewed from N Seoul Tower on Namsan, Seoul, on the 19th. Yonhap News

View original image

According to the financial sector on the 25th, recent discussions at the Financial Services Commission (FSC) on tightening regulations on loans to multiple-home owners have been gaining both speed and intensity following the president's public remarks.


When President Lee, on the 13th just before the Lunar New Year holidays, raised the issue of extending loan maturities for multiple-home owners via the social networking service X (formerly Twitter), the financial authorities began reviewing a plan to strengthen the rental income to interest repayment ratio (RTI) regulation for residential lease business operators. After that, when President Lee stated again on the 20th, "Why are you only reviewing the RTI regulation? Wouldn't it be fair if extensions or refinancing of existing loans on multiple homes were subject to the same lending regulations as those imposed on the purchase of new multiple homes?", the discussion expanded to include restrictions on extending loan maturities. The president's additional remarks effectively broadened the scope of the regulations.


The FSC has now effectively decided on a direction under which individual multiple-home owners and residential lease business operators who own apartments in regulated areas such as Seoul and the greater metropolitan area will be subject to a 0% loan-to-value (LTV) ratio when extending loan maturities, the same as for new loans. Until now, loans to lease business operators had routinely been extended upon maturity as a matter of practice, but going forward the authorities intend to have those loans repaid. However, taking market conditions into account, they have decided not to uniformly expand the regulations to include regional real estate and multi-family housing.


A financial industry official said, "When the president posts a related message on social media, the authorities infer his intent and move on to reviewing countermeasures," adding, "In effect, the detailed direction is being presented, and regulations are being designed in a top-down manner."


The problem is that the policy direction is being set before the financial authorities have fully grasped the status of loans to multiple-home owners across the financial sector. This is why there are concerns that it will be difficult to predict the regulatory impact in advance.


An official at a commercial bank explained, "When a borrower takes out a new loan, we can check how many homes they own, but if they subsequently purchase additional homes, that information is not reflected in the system," adding, "On the ground, it is difficult to accurately tally the volume of loans related to multiple-home owners."


In this regard, the financial authorities are reviewing ways to share information with related agencies such as the National Tax Service.


There is also considerable skepticism about the impact on the market. The previous day, the FSC held its third meeting on regulations for loans to multiple-home owners to review the current situation, and it was reported that, of the approximately 15 trillion won in outstanding loans to lease business operators at the five major banks, only about 10% were apartment-backed loans. In the case of individual multiple-home owners, apartments in regulated areas, where prices are relatively high, are often purchased through "gap investment," in which the buyer assumes the tenant's key money deposit, so the share of mortgage loans may not be large. In addition, given that many of these loans are structured as long-term amortizing loans with maturities of 30 years or more, some analysts say that even if the loans are called in immediately, the short-term impact on the real estate market could be limited. Accordingly, there are projections that the recovery of loans to multiple-home owners will have only a limited effect in terms of increasing the supply of apartments for sale in regulated areas.


On the other hand, there is considerable concern about heightened residential instability for tenants. In response, the financial authorities are also reviewing measures such as deferring loan recovery until the time the tenant moves out. In addition, there is speculation that if multiple-home owners come under funding pressure, they may choose to sell regional homes first rather than apartments in regulated areas.



The financial authorities plan to announce next week their household debt management plan, which will include measures to stabilize the market and protect tenants. The announcement, originally scheduled for this week, has been postponed on the grounds that more time is needed to assess the actual situation and finalize detailed measures.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing