Courtrooms Trapped by Personnel Moves, Hierarchy, and Face-Saving
Judges Say "Procedures Will Drag On Even More"
Rulings Themselves Become a Matter of "Risk Management"
Court Timelines Already Stretched Long
Delayed Justice...The Publi

[Reporter’s Notebook] How the "Three Judicial Reform Acts" Will Change Time in the Courtroom View original image

"The ○○ District Court sees a surge in not-guilty verdicts right after the February prosecutor personnel reshuffle. Wouldn't it be burdensome to deliver not-guilty verdicts to prosecutors you’ve been seeing regularly?"


Prosecutor A said that, during his time as a trial prosecutor, he was pressured to "manage the acquittal rate." When the acquittal rate at his office exceeded the national average, the chief ordered him to bring it down. He responded by mounting a “fortress-like” defense for convictions. He visited judges individually, explained the key issues, and put great effort into sustaining the prosecution. From March to December of that year, not a single acquittal was rendered.


Judgments are not made solely on the basis of the law. Variables such as personnel changes, organizational factors, statistics, and public opinion all play a role. In the legal community, it is not considered a coincidence that the number of verdicts delivered in January and February drops noticeably. When personnel transfers coincide, judges appointed to courts far from KTX stations receive numerous recruitment offers from law firms, and in a reality where entry-level associate lawyers at law firms often earn more than senior high court judges, the decision to leave the bench follows. Judges, too, weigh risks and rewards.


What might happen if another major variable, such as the "Three Judicial Reform Bills," is added? Judges unanimously say, “Procedures will become endlessly prolonged,” adding, “Postponing a hearing does not constitute punishment, does it?” From the perspective of a judge, cases with numerous complaints, significant political implications, or those likely to be overturned on appeal are handled with caution. This is to avoid criminal liability for judicial distortion. Cases are postponed repeatedly until the next personnel reshuffle. It becomes difficult to expect judges to deliver rulings based on conviction.


But can trial delays be penalized? Courtrooms are already mired in the swamp of “procedural justice,” with hundreds of pages of documentary evidence, mass witness requests, motions for recusal, and repeated renewal procedures. In the first trial of former Supreme Court Chief Justice Yang Sung-tae for abuse of judicial administrative authority, after the entire panel of judges was replaced, the defense team of former Justice Park Byung-dae requested to replay all previously recorded witness testimonies. This replay process alone took about seven months. The trial was effectively halted. If the right to file a retrial is introduced, it could easily take ten years to reach a final resolution.



There is hope that increasing the number of Supreme Court Justices from 14 to 26 will reduce the backlog of appeals. However, many expect a surge in cases due to the easing of requirements for granting appeals. Concerns about declining trust in the judiciary are valid. Still, it is important to carefully consider whether such reforms will undermine other values. In South Korea, the average duration for first-instance trials is 420.1 days in civil cases and 223.7 days in criminal cases. Over the past ten years, civil trials have lengthened by half a year and criminal trials by two additional months. If attempts to exert stricter control over verdicts end up resulting in delayed justice, it is the public who will bear the cost.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing