Eight Weeks of Treatment for Rotator Cuff Tear
Court Also Takes Passenger Negligence into Account

According to a report by Yonhap News Agency on February 21, a court has ruled that a bus operator must pay partial damages to a passenger who fell while attempting to disembark before the bus had come to a complete stop and subsequently underwent shoulder surgery.

A court has ruled that a bus operator must pay partial damages to a passenger who fell while attempting to disembark before the bus had come to a complete stop and subsequently underwent shoulder surgery.

A court has ruled that a bus operator must pay partial damages to a passenger who fell while attempting to disembark before the bus had come to a complete stop and subsequently underwent shoulder surgery.

View original image

According to the legal community on February 21, the single-judge civil division of the Busan District Court Dongbu Branch ruled in a damages lawsuit filed by Mr. A against a bus company that "the defendant shall pay the plaintiff an amount equivalent to 30% of the medical expenses, as well as 2.73 million won including consolation money, together with delay damages."


According to the judgment, at around 8:53 p.m. on July 4, 2024, Mr. A boarded a city bus in Busan. When the bus arrived at a stop near his destination, he walked toward the rear door to get off. During this process, he lost his balance and fell while the bus had not yet come to a complete stop.


As a result of the accident, Mr. A suffered a tear in his shoulder rotator cuff and was diagnosed as needing about eight weeks of treatment. The total cost of surgery, treatment, and caregiving was calculated at approximately 5.77 million won.


The court found that the carrier’s liability for compensation itself was established under the Automobile Liability Security Act. However, it limited the scope of liability after comprehensively considering the circumstances of the accident and the health condition of the victim.


The court stated, "The accident occurred while the plaintiff was moving at a time when the bus had not come to a complete stop," and explained, "Taking into account factors such as the impact of the plaintiff’s preexisting conditions on the extent of the damage, the defendant’s share of liability is set at 30%." Accordingly, it ordered the company to pay a sum that combines part of the medical expenses and 1 million won in consolation money.


In cases of accidents on public transportation, the courts determine the degree of comparative negligence by examining both the driver’s duty to ensure safety and whether passengers have fulfilled their own duty of care.


Bus and subway safety accidents most frequent among the elderly

Recently, safety accidents occurring while using public transportation such as buses and subways have been on the rise. According to data from the Consumer Injury Surveillance System compiled by the Korea Consumer Agency, there were 1,034 bus- and subway-related accidents reported from 2022 through July 2025, increasing sharply from 125 cases in 2022 to 460 cases in 2024.


By age group, the accident rate was highest among seniors aged 65 and older, at 5.08 cases per 100,000 people. Most accidents involving the elderly were falls that occurred during boarding and alighting or while moving inside the vehicle.



The Korea Consumer Agency has urged that, to prevent accidents among older adults, passengers should move only after the vehicle has come to a complete stop and should observe basic safety rules such as holding on to handrails while on board. It is also distributing related safety videos through online platforms and media screens inside buses.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing