Samsung Life sees capital surge after ending "non-standard accounting"...faces concerns over declining ROE
Samsung Fire & Marine, record-high solvency but "conservative dividends" leave shareholders saying it "falls short of expectations"
Securing competitiveness in core insurance business is key..."Overcoming head-on through performance and efficiency"

Samsung Life Insurance and Samsung Fire & Marine Insurance were unable to celebrate their strong performances, even though they overcame negative factors such as rising loss ratios and weakening growth drivers to each surpass 2 trillion won in annual net income for the third consecutive year and second consecutive year, respectively. This was because, at the earnings presentation (IR) held on February 20, they faced sharp criticism from institutional investors who said their dividends were "excessively conservative." In particular, Samsung Life Insurance, despite ending its long-disputed "non-standard accounting" practice and thereby sharply increasing its book equity capital, had to confront critical views over its decision to classify the portion attributable to participating policyholders as equity capital.


Samsung Life Insurance Seocho Building, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Samsung Life Insurance

Samsung Life Insurance Seocho Building, Seocho-gu, Seoul. Samsung Life Insurance

View original image

On that day, Samsung Life Insurance announced that last year its consolidated net income attributable to controlling shareholders increased by 9.3% year-on-year to 2.3028 trillion won. On the same day, Samsung Fire & Marine Insurance reported net income attributable to controlling shareholders of 2.0183 trillion won. However, during the one-hour earnings presentation, both companies were bombarded by institutional investors with criticism and questions regarding: inadequate shareholder return policies; plans to adjust return on equity (ROE) following the end of non-standard accounting; measures to manage and adjust loss ratios; and targets related to their value-up policies.


Samsung Life Insurance disclosed in its audit report that it had decided to reclassify the valuation gains on its Samsung Electronics stake held in the participating account, which had been managed as a separate liability item called "policyholder equity adjustment," as equity capital. As a result, its book equity capital swelled to 64.8 trillion won, an increase of 26.7 trillion won (70.1%) from 38.1 trillion won at the end of 2024. Its K-ICS (Korea-Insurance Capital Standard) ratio, a key solvency indicator, was also expected to reach 198% as of the end of last year. In other words, equity capital on the books increased and the solvency indicator improved.


However, some civic groups, as well as parts of the accounting and financial sectors, have criticized whether it is appropriate to classify as equity capital for shareholders, rather than as insurance liabilities, the gains generated by purchasing an 8.51% stake in Samsung Electronics using premiums paid by participating policyholders. In relation to this, Samsung Life Insurance added a note in its audit report stating, "This accounting change has no impact whatsoever on the rights of participating policyholders under the policy terms and conditions."


At the earnings presentation, institutional investors also expressed doubts over whether the company could truly improve ROE, its key profitability indicator, simply because non-standard accounting related to participating policies had ended and book equity had increased. One investor noted, "The disclosure item for policyholder equity has changed from 'liability' to 'equity,' but even if we exclude the valuation gains from the Samsung Electronics stake, and even if contract service margin (CSM) from the core business gradually improves and the dividend payout ratio is raised to 50% as guided, it will not be easy to further improve ROE if equity capital continues to grow," and asked what the company's mid-term plans were to enhance capital efficiency.


Lee Wansam, Chief Financial Officer (CFO) of Samsung Life Insurance, said, "We will steadily increase dividends per share and gradually improve ROE over the mid-to-long term by securing a solid new business system and by increasing stable insurance profit," but added, "It is difficult to specify and disclose a concrete dividend target, because we cannot accurately predict the timing of realizing gains from the sale of Samsung Electronics shares, and because the volatility in the size of such gains is expected to expand significantly, which we believe could act as a variable for the stable, gradual dividend increases the company is aiming for."


Samsung Insurers Keep the "2 Trillion Won Club" Status but Cannot Smile... Unprecedented Rebuke over Shareholder Returns View original image

Samsung Fire & Marine Insurance was criticized for insufficient shareholder returns. The company paid a dividend per share (DPS) of 19,500 won last year, with a shareholder return ratio of 41.1%, and announced a plan to raise the shareholder return ratio to 50% by 2028. Institutional investors responded unusually sharply to this announcement. Of the 13 questions they asked during the earnings presentation, 4 (31%) were related to shareholder return policies. They said, "This is disappointing," "The dividend is far lower than market expectations," "We question whether the gains from the disposal of Samsung Electronics shares have been fully reflected," and "Compared with the more progressive (value-up) plans of other Samsung affiliates, Samsung Fire & Marine Insurance's pace of progress is extremely slow." It is rare for criticism of such intensity to be voiced at Samsung Fire & Marine Insurance's earnings presentations.


Ku Youngmin, policy chief and CFO of Samsung Fire & Marine Insurance, said, "As we announced in our corporate value enhancement plan in January last year, our target of a 50% dividend payout ratio by 2028 remains unchanged, and we would appreciate it if investors recognized that we increased DPS even though last year's net income declined (down 2.7% year-on-year)," adding, "Realized gains from the sale of Samsung Electronics shares are reflected directly in earnings, and the retained earnings generated are then reflected in dividends."


Cho Beonhyeong, head of the management support team at Samsung Fire & Marine Insurance, also explained, "We are precisely measuring ROE by business segment and are preparing capital allocation measures to achieve our targets."



Experts advise that, for the two companies to dispel investor distrust, they ultimately need to prove the fundamental strength of their core "insurance business." Seo Jiyong, professor at the School of Business Administration at Sangmyung University, said, "It is positive that both companies have remained in the '2 trillion won net income club,' but they need to strengthen fundamentals in their core business," and added, "For Samsung Life Insurance, the most urgent tasks are to bolster capabilities in new businesses such as healthcare and pet insurance, and to improve the efficiency of sales channels at subsidiary-type corporate general agencies (GAs). For Samsung Fire & Marine Insurance, it is necessary to pursue a strategy of enhancing rate-setting based on automobile insurance data analysis to lower the loss ratio and increase operating profit."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing