'Baemin Only' promotion harms only franchise owners
Violations of the Fair Trade Act and the Franchise Business Act... "Unfair trade"

Franchisees of Cheogajip Yangnyeom Chicken have retained the law firm YK (Managing Partners: Kang Kyunghoon and Kim Beomhan) to pursue legal action, asserting that a promotion jointly conducted by the Cheogajip Yangnyeom Chicken franchise headquarters (Hanguk Il-O-Sam) and Woowa Brothers, operator of Baedal Minjok, violates the Monopoly Regulation and Fair Trade Act as well as the Franchise Business Act.


The franchisees claim that they were induced to sign an agreement offering sharply reduced brokerage fees on the condition that they exclusively transact with Baedal Minjok and do not use other delivery apps. However, they allege that exaggerated information was provided regarding the frequency and effectiveness of the promotion, and that they were not properly notified about the risks of revenue loss from not being able to use competing platforms, resulting in damages.


On July 15, 2024, in front of the Woowa Brothers headquarters in Songpa-gu, Seoul, representatives from Rider Union, the Meeting of Bosses for a Fair Platform, and the Service Federation's Delivery Platform Union are holding a press conference condemning Baedal Minjok's fee increase and calling for its withdrawal. Yonhap News

On July 15, 2024, in front of the Woowa Brothers headquarters in Songpa-gu, Seoul, representatives from Rider Union, the Meeting of Bosses for a Fair Platform, and the Service Federation's Delivery Platform Union are holding a press conference condemning Baedal Minjok's fee increase and calling for its withdrawal. Yonhap News

View original image

Furthermore, although the franchise headquarters and Woowa Brothers maintain that participation in the promotion is voluntary, the franchisees argue that, given the risk of disadvantages such as restricted app exposure, participation is in fact effectively mandatory from their perspective.

"'Baemin Only' Promotion Illegal"... YK Submits Complaint to KFTC

On the 20th, YK announced that it had filed a complaint with the Korea Fair Trade Commission (KFTC) on behalf of the Cheogajip Yangnyeom Chicken Franchisees' Association (hereafter, the Association) against Woowa Brothers, the operator of the Baedal Minjok delivery platform, and the franchise headquarters, Hanguk Il-O-Sam.


YK reported to the KFTC that the "Baemin Only" promotion carried out by Woowa Brothers and Hanguk Il-O-Sam violates both the Monopoly Regulation and Fair Trade Act (hereafter, the Fair Trade Act) and the Act on Fairness in Franchise Transactions (Franchise Business Act).


On January 27, Woowa Brothers, operator of Baedal Minjok, signed a strategic partnership memorandum of understanding (MOU) with Hanguk Il-O-Sam, which operates Cheogajip Yangnyeom Chicken, and from February 9 began offering a "Baemin Only" program granting fee reduction benefits to franchisees registered exclusively with Baedal Minjok.


According to YK, Woowa Brothers, in signing the MOU with the franchise headquarters, promised franchisees fee reductions and discount support if they conducted exclusive transactions with Baedal Minjok, eschewing other delivery apps. Specifically, they proposed to lower the brokerage fee from the existing 7.8% to 3.5%, thereby inducing exclusive deals.


YK pointed out, "Although the actual economic benefit to franchisees from the promotion is minimal, it completely deprives them of opportunities to transact via other delivery apps, potentially causing severe revenue loss." In practice, stores participating in the promotion were unable to use other delivery apps such as Coupang Eats and Yogiyo.


In particular, since the chicken franchise sector is highly competitive among brands, franchisees must bear the full burden of real revenue losses resulting from operating on a single delivery platform. Nevertheless, according to the franchisees, neither Woowa Brothers nor the headquarters made any commitments to share responsibility for losses incurred from decreased sales.


In fact, under the MOU between Woowa Brothers and the headquarters, as of the end of 2024, more than 90% of the total 1,254 franchisees were effectively forced to participate in the promotion, leading to a significant reduction in the exposure of Cheogajip Yangnyeom Chicken on other delivery apps.

Abuse of Market Dominance and Unfair Trade Under the Fair Trade Act... Provision of False, Exaggerated, or Deceptive Information and Unfair Trade Under the Franchise Business Act

According to reporting by The Asia Business Daily, YK determined that by entering into an exclusive-conditional transaction agreement, Woowa Brothers and the franchise headquarters prevented Cheogajip Yangnyeom Chicken franchisees from joining other delivery apps besides Baedal Minjok, an act constituting "transaction with binding conditions," a type of unfair trade practice under the Fair Trade Act.


Article 45(1) of the Fair Trade Act lists acts that may undermine fair trade by a business operator; subparagraph 7 prohibits "engaging in transactions with the other party under conditions that unduly restrict the business activities of the counterparty."


YK further believes that exaggerating the frequency and other aspects of the promotion to induce franchisees to sign the agreement constitutes "unfair customer inducement," another form of unfair trade practice under the Fair Trade Act.


On March 22, 2021, delivery riders of Baedal Minjok affiliated with the Baemin Riders branch of the Service General Labor Union of the Korean Confederation of Trade Unions held a rally in front of the Woowa Brothers headquarters in Bangi-dong, Songpa-gu, Seoul, demanding improved working conditions for riders. Photo by Kim Hyunmin

On March 22, 2021, delivery riders of Baedal Minjok affiliated with the Baemin Riders branch of the Service General Labor Union of the Korean Confederation of Trade Unions held a rally in front of the Woowa Brothers headquarters in Bangi-dong, Songpa-gu, Seoul, demanding improved working conditions for riders. Photo by Kim Hyunmin

View original image

Article 45(1) subparagraph 4 of the Fair Trade Act prohibits "unduly inducing a competitor's customers to trade with oneself." Violation of this provision can result in corrective orders and fines, and under Article 125(4) of the same law, criminal penalties of up to two years in prison or a fine of up to 150 million won.


YK also reported that Woowa Brothers' exclusive-conditional transaction agreement with the Cheogajip Yangnyeom Chicken franchise headquarters, which required franchisees to register solely with Baedal Minjok, constitutes "exclusion of competitors through exclusive-conditional transactions"—an abuse of market dominance prohibited under the Fair Trade Act.


Article 5(1) subparagraph 5 of the Fair Trade Act prohibits "transactions that unduly exclude competitors or are likely to significantly undermine consumer interests." Violations may be punished under Article 124(1) subparagraph 1 of the Fair Trade Act by up to three years in prison or a fine of up to 200 million won.


Meanwhile, YK reported that the franchise headquarters, Hanguk Il-O-Sam, violated Article 9(1) and Article 12(1) subparagraph 2 of the Franchise Business Act by failing to inform franchisees of matters that significantly affect their business decisions, such as the real effect of the fee reduction, the risk of sales decline from ceasing use of competing platforms, and legal risks arising from the structure of exclusive conditions when encouraging participation in the promotion.


Article 9(1) of the Franchise Business Act (Prohibition of Provision of False or Exaggerated Information) prohibits the franchise headquarters from providing information to franchisees that is untrue, exaggerated, or that conceals or downplays facts critical to the formation or maintenance of the contract (deceptive information).


Violation of this provision—by providing false, exaggerated, or deceptive information—can result in criminal penalties of up to five years in prison or a fine of up to 300 million won under Article 41(1) of the Franchise Business Act.


Article 12(1) subparagraph 2 of the Franchise Business Act prohibits "acts that unduly restrict or limit the price, trading partners, trading area, or business activities of the goods or services handled by franchisees" as a type of unfair trade practice likely to undermine fair transactions in franchise business.


Additionally, Article 48 of the Fair Trade Act (Prohibition of Retaliation) prohibits business operators from discontinuing transactions, reducing supply or imposing other disadvantages on another business operator for reporting unfair trade practices or cooperating with an investigation by the KFTC.

"Effectively Forced Participation"... Discount Sharing Ratio Inflated

The Association criticizes Woowa Brothers for leveraging its position as the market leader to induce exclusive transactions that are "nominally optional but effectively mandatory." For franchisees, the risk of app exposure restrictions and other disadvantages makes it realistically difficult to refuse participation in the promotion.


A representative of the Association stated, "The KFTC must thoroughly examine whether individual franchisees found it effectively impossible to refuse participation in the promotion, given the structure in which the delivery platform and the headquarters unilaterally concluded the MOU."


The Association also criticized the headquarters for "emphasizing only favorable conditions while failing to clearly explain the complicated settlement structure and the reality of Baedal Minjok's support funds, thereby binding franchisees to a specific platform."


Korea Fair Trade Commission Sejong Government Complex. Korea Fair Trade Commission

Korea Fair Trade Commission Sejong Government Complex. Korea Fair Trade Commission

View original image

YK further analyzed that the settlement method for the discount promotion led by Woowa Brothers and the headquarters contains serious pitfalls.


For example, when selling chicken worth 30,000 won at a discount of 8,000 won so the customer pays 22,000 won, Woowa Brothers claims to subsidize 4,000 won of the discount. At first glance, this appears to be a 50% cost-sharing arrangement.


However, in reality, the franchisee must bear a fixed discount of 4,000 won, while Woowa Brothers can unilaterally adjust the total discount amount so that it covers only 1,000 to 3,000 won—less than the franchisee's burden. In fact, in February this year, the total discount was set at 6,000 won, with the franchisee still covering 4,000 won and Woowa Brothers only 2,000 won.


Moreover, the coupons actually issued to Baedal Minjok app users are typically worth 3,000 to 4,000 won, with coupons above 8,000 won being rare. Thus, the full discount is usually borne by either the franchisee or the headquarters, and Woowa Brothers' subsidy is minimal, according to the Association.


As sales increase, Woowa Brothers' total fee revenue rises, but franchisees are left to shoulder the excessive discount amounts entirely. YK stated, "This is woefully insufficient to offset the revenue losses from being barred from using other delivery apps."


YK also found that, although the promotional materials indicated that the headquarters, regional branches, and franchisees would share the discount in certain ratios, in legal terms, it is the individual franchisees—not the headquarters—who are party to the delivery app contract and thus bear the cost of discount coupons.


YK expressed hope that the KFTC's investigation will put an end to these unfair practices, in which a dominant business operator monopolizes the market and forces franchisees to bear all the resultant damages.



Meanwhile, on January 12, YK filed a lawsuit with the Seoul Eastern District Court on behalf of over 360 franchisees of national chains such as BBQ and Baskin Robbins, seeking the return of unjust enrichment from Woowa Brothers, operator of Baedal Minjok, for having collected fees based on the pre-discount amount, not the actual payment amount.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing