Entertainment Dispute Extends to Private Messages as Court Evidence
HYBE Stresses It Was "Meant to Show Empathy"...Warns Against Overinterpretation

BTS V. BigHit Music

BTS V. BigHit Music

View original image

V of BTS has issued a statement after his private conversation with former Ador CEO Min Heejin was accepted as evidence in court.


On the 20th, V wrote on his social networking service (SNS), "It was part of a private, everyday conversation in which I empathized as an acquaintance," adding, "I had absolutely no intention of taking sides with either party." He continued, "I am very taken aback that this conversation was submitted as evidence without my consent."


On the same day, a media outlet reported that the court of first instance had accepted as evidence the messenger conversation between V and former CEO Min. In that conversation, V was quoted as saying, in relation to allegations that ILLIT is similar to NewJeans, "I saw it too and thought, 'Ah, this is similar.'"


HYBE drew a line, saying that V's remark does not mean he agreed with any particular claim. A HYBE representative said, "It was a private conversation with an acquaintance, and he only spoke in a way meant to show empathy; we have confirmed that he did not agree with the other party's specific statements," and added, "We understand that the artist has also expressed dissatisfaction that the contents of a private conversation were submitted as trial material without his consent."


On February 12, the 31st Civil Division of the Seoul Central District Court ruled that former CEO Min's exercise of her put option (stock purchase right) was valid. The court ordered HYBE to pay 25.5 billion won to former CEO Min. It also ordered the company to pay 1.7 billion won and 1.4 billion won, respectively, to former Ador Deputy CEO Shin and former Ador Director Kim, who exercised their put options together with her.


V Instagram

V Instagram

View original image

HYBE argued that former CEO Min had seriously violated the shareholders' agreement, including by attempting to "take NewJeans away," but the court did not accept this. Regarding the allegations related to ILLIT, the court stated that they were "no more than a simple opinion and value judgment to the effect that the overall impression is similar," and ruled that they "fall within the scope of managerial discretion in making decisions to protect NewJeans' interests."


HYBE, dissatisfied with the first-instance ruling, filed a notice of appeal on the 19th. The conflict between the two sides began in April 2024, when a dispute over management control surfaced. Former CEO Min initiated legal action by notifying the company in November of the same year of her intention to exercise the put option.



Meanwhile, BTS will release their fifth full-length album, "Arirang" (ARIRANG), on March 20, 2026, and begin their comeback activities.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing