Law Firms Race to Recruit Former Police Officers
Cases Disappearing at the Police Stage

[Reporter’s Notebook]The Evolution of "The Rich Are Never Guilty" into "The Rich Are Never Referred to the Prosecution" View original image

This is a period of major transformation in the criminal justice system, with the abolition of prosecutorial investigative powers and the launch of the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency (Serious Crime Unit). The legal district of Seocho-dong is bustling. Major law firms are accelerating their recruitment of former high-ranking police officers, as if they had been waiting for this moment. The emergence of massive 'police teams' within law firms—teams of more than 100 former police officers, including both lawyers and specialists—is no longer surprising.


The 2021 adjustment of investigative powers between the police and prosecution had already reshaped the law firm market. Rather than focusing on dazzling courtroom defenses, law firms now see their core competitive edge in strategies that can make cases 'disappear' at the police investigation stage. In the past, cases investigated by the police would be transferred to the prosecution regardless of their conclusions, where another legal review would take place. Now, if the police judge that there is 'no suspicion,' many cases end right at that stage. Requests from the prosecution for reinvestigation account for only about 3% of cases. This structure has only become more entrenched, especially now that even the complainant's right to appeal has disappeared.


The launch of the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency is expected to further solidify this trend. The core of the new system is the strict separation of investigation and indictment. As a result, legal defense strategies are inevitably shifting from the post-indictment courtroom stage to responding at the investigative stage. This is why the value of former police officers, who can read the 'grammar of police investigations,' is skyrocketing.


From the perspective of law firms, it may seem only natural to follow market logic. However, serious doubts remain about whether the oversight mechanisms are robust enough to keep pace with the ever-expanding investigative powers. If crimes involving major capital or corruption within the police itself are closed at an early stage, there will be no way to correct miscarriages of justice. The lament of a current chief prosecutor—"Is it reasonable for the investigative body and the body making the final disposition to be one and the same?"—cannot be dismissed as mere organizational self-interest.


Ultimately, the concern is the polarization of justice. Those with the means can hire high-priced former police officers to deftly dodge the blade of investigation, while ordinary citizens who have suffered harm may find themselves anxiously waiting without even knowing why their cases were closed. The old adage "the rich are never guilty" is now evolving into "the rich are never indicted" as cases disappear in the investigative stage.



If the era of the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency is to truly realize investigative efficiency, discussions must also address how to design external review mechanisms for non-indictment decisions, including the possible revival of mandatory case transfers. Careful consideration is also needed for the potential vacuum in judicial oversight if even the last bastion of corrective investigation rights is rendered powerless. Unchecked authority always carries the risk of misjudgment and arbitrariness. The credibility of the justice system depends not on the magnitude of its powers, but on how those powers are kept in check.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing