Appeals Court: "Crimes Not Specifically Established"
Settlements and Deposits Taken into Account
Prison Sentence Reduced from 8 Years to 4 Years

The prison sentence of a principal who was given eight years in prison in the first trial for molesting and sexually abusing elementary school students aged 6 to 11 in his principal's office was cut in half on appeal.


The Asia Business Daily Database

The Asia Business Daily Database

View original image

According to Yonhap News on the 19th, the Criminal Division 1 of the Chuncheon Panel of the Seoul High Court (Presiding Judge Lee Eunhye) sentenced Mr. A (63) to four years in prison at the appellate sentencing hearing on charges of indecent acts by abuse of authority against a minor under the age of 13 under the Act on the Protection of Children and Juveniles from Sexual Abuse, and child abuse by a child welfare facility worker under the Child Welfare Act.


Mr. A, who had been serving as principal since September 2022, was brought to trial on charges of using his authority to molest and sexually abuse, including repeated sexual harassment, 10 victims under the age of 13 in the principal's office and on the playground about 250 times from early April 2023 to the end of December 2023.


Although Mr. A was a mandatory reporter of child abuse crimes, instead of protecting the children he committed sex crimes against young students whose sexual self-determination had not yet been established. The investigation found that, with the exception of two incidents that occurred on the playground, all of the offenses took place in the principal's office.


The crimes came to light when friends of one of the victims, seeking to help the victim, filmed the criminal acts, created a group chat room to discuss countermeasures, and collected evidence. The case also surfaced when a student who had suffered multiple instances of abuse heard about another student's victimization and then confided their own experience to their parents.


In the first trial, the court found all of the charges to be guilty, citing, among other things, the consistency of the victims' statements, and sentenced Mr. A to eight years in prison, ordered him to complete 80 hours each of a sexual violence treatment program and a child abuse treatment program, and imposed a 10-year employment restriction from institutions related to children and adolescents.


However, Mr. A appealed the ruling. In the appellate trial, he argued that "of the approximately 250 incidents specified, nearly 200 are so unclear that they infringe on my right to defense and therefore cannot be regarded as having been specifically alleged in the indictment."


The appellate court held that the roughly 180 incidents included in the indictment were merely a mechanically calculated number based on the victimized child's statement to the investigative authorities that they "were victimized almost every day or two to three times a week."


The court also found that the description of the method of the crimes was selective, and that even taking into account the inherent difficulty of specifying the exact dates of offenses in a long-term, repeated child molestation case, it was hard to view the indictment as having sufficiently specified the charges.



Accordingly, the court dismissed the prosecution for those charges and, taking into account circumstances such as Mr. A having reached settlements with some of the victimized children or having deposited criminal compensation with the court, overturned the original eight-year sentence and instead sentenced him to four years in prison. However, the court maintained the original ruling on the protective (security) measures.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing