Court Acknowledges Yoon as Leader of Insurrection
But Stops Short of Imposing Death Penalty

May 18 Groups Say Ruling "Leaves a Scar on History"
A Verdict Far Removed from Public Legal Sentiment

On the 19th, at Seoul Station, citizens watched news about the first-instance sentencing of former president Yoon Sukyeol, who was indicted on charges of being the ringleader of the insurrection related to the December 3 emergency martial law. Yonhap News

On the 19th, at Seoul Station, citizens watched news about the first-instance sentencing of former president Yoon Sukyeol, who was indicted on charges of being the ringleader of the insurrection related to the December 3 emergency martial law. Yonhap News

View original image

After the first-instance court sentenced former President Yoon Sukyeol, who was indicted on charges of leading an insurrection in connection with the 2024 "12-3 emergency martial law" incident, to life imprisonment, May 18 organizations and civil society groups in Gwangju unanimously expressed strong regret and anger, calling it "an excessively lenient slap-on-the-wrist punishment for the main culprit of the coup." The predominant criticism was that the ruling amounted to a kind of compromise that failed to reflect the public sentiment of citizens who had been calling for the death penalty.


On the afternoon of the 19th, the 25th Criminal Division of the Seoul Central District Court (Presiding Judge Ji Guyoun) held a sentencing hearing for former President Yoon, who was indicted on charges of leading an insurrection and abusing his authority by obstructing the exercise of others' rights, and sentenced him to life imprisonment. This was the judiciary's first ruling, handed down 443 days after the declaration of emergency martial law on December 3, 2024. The court stated, "Even if the declaration of martial law is a power guaranteed to the president under the Constitution, we judge this to be an insurrection aimed at disrupting the constitutional order," adding, "From the declaration of martial law to the occupation of the National Election Commission, all of it constitutes a riot, and therefore the charge of leading an insurrection is guilty." He thus avoided the death penalty, which the special prosecutor had sought as the maximum statutory sentence.


Once the sentencing result became known, people from all walks of civil society in Gwangju, regarded as the sacred ground of democracy, could not hide their deep disappointment and regret.


Yoon Mokhyeon, Chairperson of the May 18 Memorial Foundation, strongly criticized the ruling, saying, "Today's sentencing result is deeply regrettable when viewed against the legal sentiment of the majority of the people and the weight of historical responsibility," and, "Given the gravity of a case that shook the constitutional order, it is hard to avoid criticism that this decision did not sufficiently meet expectations for social justice."


He went on to say, "Judicial decisions must be respected, but in the appellate trial we strongly urge that the law and evidence be examined even more strictly so that a conclusion commensurate with the level of responsibility is reached," calling for the firm establishment of the principles of the rule of law and democracy.


Park Kangbae, Standing Executive Director of the May 18 Memorial Foundation, also stated, "This has inflicted yet another wound on history. It makes people think, 'So even a president can carry out a coup,' and it treats the people with contempt, resulting in the erosion of the rule of law," adding, "In a situation where the insurrectionist forces still show no remorse and continue to disregard the law and the people, a life sentence is far too light a punishment compared to the crime."


Organizations of May 18 merit recipients also issued strong condemnations.


Yang Jaehyeok, President of the Association of Bereaved Families of May 18 Democratic Merit Recipients, rebuked the ruling, saying, "The judiciary today denied on its own why the spirit of May 18 was written in blood," and, "The judiciary must painfully remember that this ruling will remain in history forever."


Shin Gukjeong, President of the May 18 Democratization Movement Wounded Association, a public-law organization, likewise added, "Even if one says there is no other choice because it is within the judge's discretion, it is a highly unsatisfactory ruling and will ultimately serve only to fuel public distrust in the court."


Civic groups and legal circles also voiced criticism along with practical concerns.


Cho Seonik, Co-Representative of Participatory Autonomy 21, said, "There is a clear gap between this sentence and the legal sentiment of citizens who wanted the death penalty, the maximum statutory punishment," but added, "Still, it is at least fortunate that the insurrection charge was recognized and that a life sentence was handed down." He went on, "Given that there is a high possibility that most of those involved in the insurrection, including Yoon Sukyeol, will refuse to accept the ruling and show no remorse, there must never be a case in the future where the main culprits of the insurrection are pardoned under the pretext of political interests."


Son Sangyong, Chair of the Steering Committee of the Gwangju-Jeonnam Labor Safety and Health Guardians, also said, "This ruling carries the meaning of condemning those in power for destroying democracy and wrecking the lives of the people," but expressed regret by adding, "To ensure that such destruction of democracy and plotting of insurrection is never repeated, the death penalty should have been imposed as a stern warning and exemplary punishment."


Legal professionals expressed disappointment, yet coolly assessed the practical significance of the ruling.


Attorney Kim Joungho, Chair of the May 18 Special Committee of the Gwangju-Jeonnam Branch of Lawyers for a Democratic Society (Minbyun), said, "It is disappointing that the court chose life imprisonment while leaving the maximum statutory sentence, the death penalty, unused, which makes it seem as though the court opted for a kind of compromise," but added, "We still ascribe positive meaning to the fact of a heavy sentence itself, in that it makes clear that the insurrection committed by Yoon Sukyeol must never be repeated in the Republic of Korea and offers some consolation to the many citizens who tried to defend democracy."



Song Changun, Head of the Gwangju-Jeonnam Branch of Minbyun, sharply criticized the court's reasoning. He said, "The gist of the ruling that former President Yoon and others tried to minimize violence over a short period is utterly incomprehensible and hard to empathize with, and it leaves an unpleasant impression that the court is lessening the defendants' responsibility and siding with them." However, regarding sentencing, he analyzed, "It appears the court was very much mindful of the reality that our country is, in effect, a state that has suspended executions, as well as of the ongoing controversy over the constitutionality of the death penalty," adding, "Given that the practical enforceability of the death penalty is low, the fact that the court imposed life imprisonment rather than life penal servitude seems to have been the most realistic judgment the bench could make."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing