Gwangju District Court Dismisses Appeal, Upholds Original Ruling
Defense of "Justifiable Act" Not Accepted

Exterior view of Gwangju High Court.

Exterior view of Gwangju High Court.

View original image

YouTubers who trespassed into another person's dog breeding facility, claiming they would report animal abuse, were again sentenced to fines on appeal.


The Criminal Division 2 of the Gwangju District Court (Appellate Division, Presiding Judge Kim Jongseok) announced on the 19th that it had dismissed the defendants' appeal and, as in the original trial, sentenced three people including A (58), who were indicted on charges including violation of the Act on the Punishment of Violent Acts (joint residential intrusion), to fines ranging from 3 million won to 4 million won.


A and the others were indicted on charges of trespassing without permission into a dog breeding facility (stud-dog farm) operated by B in Haenam-gun, South Jeolla Province, on August 28, 2024.


They, who are YouTubers and also members of an animal rights protection organization, suspected that B was illegally slaughtering dogs and reported this to the police and the local government. It was found that they then entered the premises without the business owner's consent, saying they would livestream the government inspection on YouTube and collect evidence.


In the process, A and the others were also charged with insult for allegedly swearing at B's family and making derogatory remarks about their appearance in front of about 30 people, including enforcement officials and police officers. However, the insult charge was dismissed in the first trial because the victims did not wish to see them punished.


During the trial, A and the others argued that "our actions served a public-interest purpose for animal protection and constituted a justifiable act to collect evidence of illegal conduct," but the court did not accept this claim.



The appellate court stated, "It is recognized that the defendants trespassed into the business premises and disturbed the peace of the residence," and added, "The original court determined the sentence after comprehensively considering factors such as the motive and circumstances of the crime, and the sentence does not appear to deviate from the reasonable bounds of discretion or be so heavy as to be unjust."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing