Governance Forum: "Exceptions to Mandatory Treasury Share Retirement? A Step Back for KOSDAQ Normalization"
"The very idea of granting small and medium-sized enterprise (SME) exceptions to listed companies is the problem. If that was the plan, they should not have gone public in the first place." The Korea Corporate Governance Forum strongly criticized the third amendment to the Commercial Act, which mandates the retirement of treasury shares, saying, "Recognizing exceptions to treasury share retirement for SMEs runs completely counter to the government's goal of normalizing the KOSDAQ market."
In a commentary released on the 19th, the Forum stated, "We oppose the revised version of the third Commercial Act amendment that exempts treasury shares held by small and mid-sized companies for the purpose of management control defense, as well as treasury shares held for specific purposes," adding this position. This is a rebuttal to arguments, mainly from the opposition bloc and the business community, that an exception to mandatory retirement of treasury shares is needed when those shares are used to defend management control, at a time when the National Assembly is expected to vote on the third amendment to the Commercial Act at a plenary session on the 24th.
First, responding to the business community's claim that "treasury shares are an essential tool for defending management control," the Forum argued, "The concept of management control exists only in Korea," and pointed out that "Management control is not a right, but a responsibility of the board of directors." It further argued, "Treating this as if it were a right of the controlling shareholder to be defended amounts to privatizing the board, skipping fairness review based on fiduciary duty in conflict-of-interest situations, and turning the board into a servant of the controlling shareholder's private interests rather than those of all shareholders. This is a breach of trust and a form of gaslighting."
The Governance Forum, which consists of more than 120 domestic and overseas members including finance professionals, legal experts, and academics, is a non-profit incorporated association that pursues the advancement of the capital market by improving corporate governance.
The Forum stated, "The reason a principle of mandatory retirement of treasury shares is needed in Korea is the abnormal behavior of controlling shareholders and management to date," and pointed out, "Korean companies have bought back their own shares with ordinary shareholders' money, claiming it was to enhance shareholder value, and then used those shares to defend management control."
It continued, "Because such behavior has been repeated, foreign investors do not recognize it as shareholder return even when Korean companies buy back their own shares," and stressed, "Given the uniquely Korean circumstances, a law mandating the retirement of treasury shares is essential from the standpoint of investor protection, and this is a problem brought on by the controlling shareholders themselves."
Earlier, at the beginning of 2024, the Forum conducted a survey of foreign investors such as pension funds and mega funds, and it was confirmed that more than 80% of foreign investors responded that they do not recognize share repurchases without retirement as shareholder return. The Forum explained, "The more experience foreign investors had in the Korean market, the more cynical they were about treasury shares, as they felt they had been stabbed in the back multiple times in the past," adding, "A representative of one of the world's leading sovereign wealth funds in charge of Korea also clearly stated, 'In Korea, treasury shares are not often retired, so we do not reflect them in per-share indicators.'"
In addition, citing a 2025 paper by Harvard Business School professors Elliott Tobin and Charles Wang in the United States, it argued, "An analysis of 15 years of data from 17 countries that have legally approved share buybacks concluded that, after authorization to acquire treasury shares, investment by all listed companies (capital expenditures plus R&D) actually increased by 8% to 10%." The Forum emphasized, "Legalizing treasury share buybacks plays a role in enhancing the efficiency of resource allocation by allowing capital to circulate from mature, low-growth, cash-rich companies to high-growth companies that lack cash."
Accordingly, the Forum argued that an exception clause for small and mid-sized companies could, as in last year's case of strengthened capital gains tax on large shareholders, cause confusion among domestic and foreign investors regarding the direction of government policy. The Forum countered, "Treasury share buybacks have a large positive effect on the national economy, and in Korea's unique situation, where controlling shareholders dominate the board and use corporate funds to strengthen their control, retirement is unavoidable," adding, "Cases of serious infringement of shareholder rights are more frequent among small companies and KOSDAQ startups than among large corporations."
It went on to say, "The surest way to revive KOSDAQ is to strengthen corporate governance at startups listed on KOSDAQ," and emphasized, "Normalization of the KOSDAQ market must be achieved from a fundamentals perspective through ecosystem improvement, corporate governance enhancement, and stricter delisting, rather than through artificial measures such as improving supply and demand, if bubbles are to be avoided."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Specifically, it called for the introduction of a "Model Articles of Incorporation." The Model Articles, released in March 2024, strengthen governance principles beyond the Standard Articles of Incorporation of the Korea Listed Companies Association, with a stronger focus on enhancing board independence and protecting minority shareholders. Article 47 of the Model Articles includes a provision requiring companies to mandatorily retire treasury shares acquired by the company within three months, while Article 10 significantly tightens the requirements for third-party allotment paid-in capital increases. The Forum stated, "For sustainable long-term growth, we recommend that companies listed not only on KOSPI but also on KOSDAQ adopt the Model Articles of Incorporation."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.