Supreme Court: Introducing Constitutional Complaints Against Court Judgments Is Unconstitutional... Will Plunge the Public Into a 'Litigation Hell'
“An Unconstitutional Idea That Violates the Separation of Judicial Powers
Impossible to Introduce Under the Current Constitution”
Concerns Over De Facto ‘Fourth Instance’ System
“Inevitable Abuse by Losing Parties and Delays in Trials”
The Supreme Court has stated that the move to introduce the so-called “constitutional complaint against court judgments,” which would make court rulings subject to review by the Constitutional Court, not only runs counter to the current Constitution but could also cause serious harm to the public.
On the 18th, the Supreme Court distributed a reference document titled “Q&A on Constitutional Complaint Against Court Judgments,” and presented its views mainly in the form of answers to questions raised during the legislative review process, stating this position. On the 13th, the Constitutional Court released materials asserting the legitimacy of introducing such a complaint system, setting up a head-on clash between the two top judicial institutions around the Lunar New Year holidays.
The Supreme Court first made it clear that, under our constitutional framework, constitutional complaints against court judgments are not permissible. It explained that, when the current Constitution was enacted in 1987 and the Constitutional Court was newly established, the decision not to allow such complaints was made in order to divide the authority to interpret the Constitution between the courts and the Constitutional Court, thereby providing stronger protection for the fundamental rights of the people.
The Supreme Court stated, “The Constitution grants to the courts alone the judicial power to interpret and apply laws in specific cases,” and pointed out, “Because the authority to make a final review of the constitutionality of orders and rules is allocated to the Supreme Court, the system does not contemplate one institution re-examining the judgments of another.” It went on to add, “The assertion that the Constitutional Court is the sole and final interpreter of the Constitution is not true,” and explained, “Germany, which the Constitutional Court cites as its model, has a fundamentally different constitutional structure from ours, including the fact that its constitutional court belongs to the judiciary, so the German-style constitutional complaint against court judgments cannot simply be imported as is.”
The Court also voiced concerns about potential harm to the public. It warned that, if such a complaint system is introduced, it would in effect function as a “fourth instance,” be abused by losing parties as another avenue of challenge, and lead to a state of “litigation hell.” The Supreme Court said, “Some argue that, because the constitutional complaint is a supplementary and exceptional remedy procedure, it is not a fourth instance but a ‘constitutional review,’ but this argument ignores reality,” adding, “If judgments of annulment, subsequent rulings, and new constitutional complaints against those rulings are repeated, the number of trials could increase far more than before.”
It also raised concerns that the Constitutional Court would not be able to cope with the volume of such cases. According to the Supreme Court, it currently takes the Constitutional Court more than two years on average to handle 2,500 cases annually. Even if constitutional complaints were allowed only against Supreme Court judgments, if more than 15,000 such cases were filed each year, this would result in constitutional adjudications being delayed by several times.
The Supreme Court stressed, “The basic ideas and design of the Constitution cannot be easily altered by a simple amendment to ordinary law,” and, “For such a fundamental institutional change, there must be consent and a shared consensus among the majority of the people, who hold the constituent power to amend the Constitution.”
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
It continued, “As for the various problems in litigation procedures that would arise from the introduction of constitutional complaints against court judgments, the bill was passed without sufficient discussion and review, simply following the Constitutional Court’s hastily presented opinion,” and added, “The way to minimize harm to the public is to go through a process of public discussion and consultation via a committee in which the National Assembly, the courts, the Constitutional Court, and experts on litigation procedures all participate.”
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.