Over 59,000 Sign Petition Against Mandatory Adoption
"Invasion of Privacy"...Concerns Raised Over Technological Maturity

Starting on March 23 next month, facial authentication is scheduled to become mandatory in the mobile phone subscription process, fueling growing controversy over personal data infringement and the stability of the technology.


According to the National Assembly on the 18th, a petition titled "Opposition to the Mandatory Facial Recognition Policy for Mobile Phone Subscription," submitted in December last year, has received consent from 59,660 people. The petition has been referred to the Science, ICT, Broadcasting and Communications Committee and is awaiting review by the standing committee.


The mandatory facial recognition measure requires taking a photo of the user’s face along with their ID when opening a mobile phone line, and comparing them in real time, with the stated aim of blocking fraudulent subscriptions using forged photos or videos. The government has said this is an unavoidable measure to prevent identity theft and voice phishing.


A mobile phone store in Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

A mobile phone store in Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News

View original image

However, the petitioner argued that mandatory facial recognition poses a serious risk of infringing on the right to informational self-determination and the freedom of privacy. In particular, as facial data is highly sensitive information that is difficult to recover once leaked, the petitioner contended that the policy should be re-examined to determine whether it complies with the principles of data minimization and proportionality.


Civic groups have also raised concerns. People’s Solidarity for Participatory Democracy, the Digital Justice Network, and the Digital Information Committee of Lawyers for a Democratic Society, among others, held a press conference in front of the Government Complex Seoul on the 11th and announced that they had filed a complaint with the Personal Information Protection Commission, calling for the policy to be halted or reconsidered.


They pointed out that, in a system where facial data is demanded without any alternative method, it is difficult to regard consent as "freely given," and that under the current legal framework there is no provision that designates facial data as a mandatory means of identity verification. They also voiced concern that digitally vulnerable groups, such as older people, persons with disabilities, and foreigners, could be excluded from using services if they fail authentication.


The photo is not related to the article.

The photo is not related to the article.

View original image

The government maintains that it will proceed with implementation as scheduled. Authorities explained that they have improved recognition rates through pilot operations, and have completed technical enhancements to reduce errors caused by lighting and angles, as well as improvements to the user environment. They also stressed that facial data will not be stored separately after authentication and will be destroyed immediately.


However, within the industry there is still a prevailing sense of unease about the maturity of the technology. One industry official said, "Some assessments put the current recognition success rate at around 60%," and added, "If it is not stabilized to at least 95% or higher before full-scale implementation, delays in sign-ups and an increase in complaints will be inevitable." Although discussions between the government and the industry are ongoing, some argue that specific improvement metrics and supplementary plans need to be disclosed more transparently.



Experts say that if technological stability and user acceptance are not sufficiently secured, initial confusion may be unavoidable, and they view the pace of improvements during the remaining period and effective communication on the ground as the key to successfully establishing the system.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing