"An Attempt to Transform the Constitutional Court into the Supreme Court"
"Endless Refusal to Accept Judgments Is a Chronic Social Problem"

"It not only violates the Constitution, but also risks creating a 'litigation hell' that brings nothing but added suffering to the people without any real benefit."


According to the legal community on the 15th, Mo Seongjun (50, 32nd class of the Judicial Research and Training Institute), a senior judge and professor at the Judicial Research and Training Institute, made this point in a post titled "Thoughts on the Discussion of Constitutional Complaints against Court Decisions" on the court's internal bulletin board (CourtNet) the previous day.


Supreme Court on the 18th. (This photo is not directly related to the article.) Photo by Yonhap News

Supreme Court on the 18th. (This photo is not directly related to the article.) Photo by Yonhap News

View original image

In the post, Professor Mo wrote, "In the Joseon Dynasty, not only the central agencies such as the Ministry of Justice, the Ministry of Taxation, and Hansungbu, but also provincial governors and local magistrates all had judicial authority. However, because jurisdictional boundaries were vague, it was commonplace for commoners to go from one office to another seeking judgments on the same case," and added, "In particular, whenever a local magistrate was replaced, those who had lost in previous trials would bring their cases again, appealing their grievances. This 'endless refusal to accept court decisions' was a chronic social problem."


He continued, "On top of a culture in which the people did not accept court rulings, turf wars over pride between government offices and frequent intervention by higher authorities led to ever-longer trials, which in turn pushed aside important disputes that needed urgent resolution," and explained, "To deal with the flood of cases, magistrates tried to forcibly close even civil disputes by administering corporal punishment, and the king repeatedly promulgated laws limiting the number of trials, but these measures had little effect."


He then added, "Joseon, which was a 'litigation hell' from which no one could escape, vividly demonstrates how powerless a judicial system becomes when limited judicial resources are combined with the normalization of non-acceptance of judgments."


Mo Seongjun, Professor at the Judicial Research and Training Institute. Yonhap News Agency

Mo Seongjun, Professor at the Judicial Research and Training Institute. Yonhap News Agency

View original image

Senior Judge Mo believes that the proposed introduction of constitutional complaints against court decisions could cause similar problems. He stressed, "On the surface, constitutional complaints against court decisions claim to protect the fundamental rights of the people, but in substance they will recreate, in a modern form, Joseon-era history of 'repeated lawsuits' and 'refusal to accept judgments' by leaving open a path for parties who cannot accept a ruling to return to square one at any time."


Professor Mo also pointed out that "the current discussion on constitutional complaints against court decisions is skewed toward a 'power-structure approach' in which the Constitutional Court, an external body, seeks to control the courts that hold judicial power, rather than toward measures to enhance the persuasiveness of judgments and the rate at which they are accepted," and he criticized the Constitutional Complaint against Court Decisions Act as "an attempt to effectively transform the Constitutional Court into the supreme court."


He further noted that constitutional complaints against court decisions could affect the structure of judicial power. Senior Judge Mo said, "The mere possibility that the rulings of the highest court can be overturned by another body instills in the public the perception that even Supreme Court judgments can be reversed," and added, "Where the authority of the judiciary has collapsed, political strife and endless conflict will take root."


Professor Mo explained, "What we should be grappling with now is not 'who controls whom,' but 'how we can properly redress the grievances of the people in the fact-finding trials and bring cases to a swift close,'" and continued, "Genuine judicial reform does not come from a bizarre multi-tiered court structure that circumvents the provisions of the Constitution, but must begin with the massive投入 of human and material resources into the fact-finding instances in order to enhance the completeness and persuasiveness of judgments."



Meanwhile, the constitutional complaint against court decisions is a system that would make court judgments subject to constitutional review. The Constitutional Court supports the idea, arguing that "the judiciary must also be bound by fundamental rights," whereas the Supreme Court opposes it on the grounds that "because it is essentially an appeal against a Supreme Court ruling rendered in the third instance, it would in effect create a four-instance system."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing