Over 25 Years, "Average First-Instance Sentence Rises from 11.5 to 17.5 Years"

The average sentence handed down in first-instance trials for murder has steadily increased from the late 1990s to recent years. Analysts say that the gap between sentences in the first and second instances has clearly narrowed, indicating greater stability in sentencing decisions.


On February 15, Yonhap News reported on the main findings of a recent report titled "An Empirical Analysis of Sentencing Decisions Before and After the Introduction of Sentencing Guidelines: Focusing on Murder Offenses" by Research Fellow Hong Boram at the Judicial Policy Research Institute, a research body under the Supreme Court. Suspended sentences and death sentences were treated as extreme values and were therefore excluded from the statistical calculations.


(This photo is not directly related to the article.) Pixabay Pixabay

(This photo is not directly related to the article.) Pixabay Pixabay

View original image

According to the report, in cases where a fixed-term prison sentence was imposed, the average sentence in first-instance murder convictions increased from "11 years and 6 months" in 1998 to "11 years and 8 months" in 2003, "11 years and 5 months" in 2008, "13 years and 2 months" in 2013, "15 years and 8 months" in 2018, and "17 years and 6 months" in 2023. Over the past 25 years, the average first-instance sentence for murder has thus increased by about six years.


In appellate courts, the average sentence rose steadily from "9 years and 4 months" in 1998 to "17 years and 10 months" in 2023. When life imprisonment is converted to a 60-year term for statistical purposes, the first-instance average dropped sharply from "25 years and 1 month" in 1998 to "15 years and 6 months" in 2008, then rose again to reach "22 years and 3 months" in 2023.


Over the same period, the average sentence in second-instance trials also decreased from 19 years and 11 months (in 1998) to 13 years and 6 months (in 2008), before increasing again to 21 years and 9 months (in 2023).


In this regard, the report noted that relatively many robbery-murder cases occurred in the late 1990s, and that a significant number of those cases resulted in life imprisonment, which affected the statistics.


The report also compared average sentence levels before and after 2009, when sentencing guidelines for murder offenses were introduced. Sentencing guidelines are recommended sentencing ranges set by the Supreme Court for each type of crime and serve as a kind of guideline that judges refer to when handing down sentences. They do not have binding legal force but do carry recommendatory effect.


The analysis found that, in the three years before the introduction of sentencing guidelines (1998, 2003, and 2008), the average fixed-term prison sentences in first and second instances were 11 years and 6 months, and 10 years and 7 months, respectively. In the three years after the introduction (2013, 2018, and 2023), the averages rose to 15 years and 4 months, and 14 years and 11 months, respectively.


Although it is commonly believed that sentences are reduced on appeal, the empirical analysis of murder cases showed that, over time, the rate at which second-instance courts overturned first-instance rulings has declined, and the gap between first- and second-instance sentences has also narrowed.



Meanwhile, since the introduction of sentencing guidelines, the gap between prosecutors' sentence recommendations and the actual sentences imposed has also narrowed significantly. Before the guidelines were introduced, first- and second-instance fixed-term prison sentences were at 65% and 56% of the prosecution's recommendations, respectively, whereas after the introduction, they rose to 71% and 68%, respectively.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing