Seismic shifts by country over independent vs. joint development
France puts the brakes on Europe's joint development program

The landscape of sixth-generation fighter development competition is changing. Conflicts are emerging among partner countries in joint development programs, and countries leading development are shifting their focus from airframe performance to artificial intelligence (AI) and manned-unmanned teaming, signaling a change in how these projects are unfolding.


Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image


FCAS on the brink of collapse over France's demand for a larger stake

The leading countries that fired the starting gun on joint development of a sixth-generation fighter are France, Germany, and Spain. They are pursuing the Future Combat Air System (FCAS). FCAS is a manned-unmanned integrated weapon system that includes a sixth-generation fighter, combat drones, a combat cloud, and more. With project costs estimated at over 100 billion euros (173 trillion won), it is the largest weapons program in European history. In 2017, French President Emmanuel Macron and then German Chancellor Angela Merkel agreed on a target of putting the system into operation by 2040, and Spain later joined the program.


France is the country that has hit the brakes. It is insisting on expanding its stake. The argument is that Dassault Aviation of France is effectively responsible for the design and key components, and therefore deserves a larger share of the program. Back in the 1980s, France also took part for a time in discussions with the United Kingdom, Germany, Italy, and Spain on developing the Eurofighter Typhoon, but ultimately went on to independently produce the Rafale fighter. As a result, Germany has decided to seriously explore cooperation with other countries. Options being discussed include working with Swedish defense company Saab, which produces the Gripen fighter, or joining the United Kingdom, Italy, and Japan in the Global Combat Air Programme (GCAP).


Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni and German opposition leader Friedrich Merz are reported to have discussed the possibility of Germany participating in GCAP during talks last month. Saab CEO Micael Johansson said in an interview with a German outlet in December last year, "If the two governments clearly express their political will, we are ready to jointly develop a fighter with Germany."


Saudi Arabia left out in the cold

Saudi Arabia has so far failed to find partners for joint development of a sixth-generation fighter. The United Kingdom, Italy, and Japan signed a treaty last month to jointly develop a sixth-generation fighter under the Global Combat Air Programme (GCAP). GCAP aims to deploy into service by 2035 a fighter with dramatically enhanced supersonic performance and radar detection capabilities. Saudi Arabia has repeatedly expressed its desire to join GCAP. Crown Prince and Prime Minister Mohammed bin Salman Al Saud conveyed this wish directly to Japanese Prime Minister Fumio Kishida in person. However, Japan is reported to have opposed the idea, saying that much of the work has already been completed and that the schedule to finish the project by 2035 is extremely tight.


The US and China dominate next-generation fighter development

The United States is pushing the Next Generation Air Dominance (NGAD) program to develop a sixth-generation fighter. The US Air Force has selected Boeing's F-47 to replace the F-22 stealth fighter. A prototype is being built with the aim of fielding the aircraft in the 2030s, and the first test flight is planned for 2028. The United States also plans to focus on developing Collaborative Combat Aircraft (CCA), including unmanned combat aircraft, going forward.


Is the Landscape of Sixth-Generation Fighter Development Changing? [Yang Nakgyu's Defence Club] View original image


The US Navy is pursuing a separate program from the Air Force. It is the next-generation carrier-based aircraft program (F/A-XX), which will be responsible for the future of carrier strike groups. Boeing and Northrop Grumman have entered the competition for the contract. The F/A-XX program aims to develop a sixth-generation fighter that will serve as the US Navy's mainstay aircraft in the 2040s. This aircraft, which must replace the current mainstay F/A-18E/F Super Hornet, differs in nature from the US Air Force's next-generation fighter. The sixth-generation carrier-based aircraft, which will also replace electronic warfare aircraft, is expected to be operated from aircraft carriers alongside the F-35C.


China's next-generation fighters to counter the United States

China plans to develop a sixth-generation fighter while simultaneously increasing the number of its fifth-generation fighters. The Royal United Services Institute (RUSI), a UK think tank, has analyzed that by 2030, around 1,000 fifth-generation J-20 fighters (including the J-20A and J-20S) and about 900 4.5-generation J-16 fighters could be in operational service. It estimated that the number of J-20s operated by the Chinese military increased from around 50 in 2020 to about 300 last year, while over a similar period the J-16 fleet grew from 90–100 aircraft to around 450.


On the 3rd, the U.S. nuclear-powered aircraft carrier USS Carl Vinson (CVN-70), which docked at the Busan operational base, had F/A-18 fighters and other aircraft lined up on its flight deck. Photo by the Joint Press Corps

On the 3rd, the U.S. nuclear-powered aircraft carrier USS Carl Vinson (CVN-70), which docked at the Busan operational base, had F/A-18 fighters and other aircraft lined up on its flight deck. Photo by the Joint Press Corps

View original image


China is currently developing two types of sixth-generation fighters, the J-36 and J-50. They are characterized by having three engines and a tailless triangular shape. They are designed to integrate advanced wideband stealth capabilities and to be optimized for high-speed air-to-air missions at high altitude. Missile performance has also been improved. China is operating air-to-air missiles such as the PL-15 and PL-17, which have a much longer range than equivalent weapons fielded by the United States, Europe, or Russia. There is also a strong possibility that China will soon field the PL-16, or may already have begun deploying it.


Korea at a crossroads between independent and joint development

Korea's planned sixth-generation fighter will be based on the KF-21. The KF-21 is a 4.5-generation fighter with limited stealth capabilities. Korea Aerospace Industries (KAI), buoyed by the successful progress of the KF-21, plans to move directly from developing a fifth-generation stealth fighter at the Block-3 stage to developing a sixth-generation manned-unmanned teaming (MUM-T) system.



Is the Landscape of Sixth-Generation Fighter Development Changing? [Yang Nakgyu's Defence Club] View original image


The unmanned aircraft that will fly alongside the KF-21 is expected to be developed by Korean Air. Korean Air developed the Kaori-X1 unmanned aircraft in 2014. The Kaori-X1 is a scaled-down airframe representing 46% of a large unmanned combat air vehicle, measuring 10.4 meters in length, 14.8 meters in wingspan, and weighing 10 tons. The Kaori-X1 demonstrated the potential for developing an unmanned combat aircraft by flying 50 kilometers over 1 hour and 30 minutes. Korean Air plans to go further and use the Kaori-X1 to develop a "loyal wingman" and a "stealth unmanned reconnaissance aircraft." The loyal wingman will enable manned-unmanned cooperative operations known as MUM-T. Before a manned fighter with a pilot on board penetrates enemy territory, a stealth loyal wingman will go in first. It can engage the enemy or conduct reconnaissance missions at the front line. Naturally, this helps protect the lives of fighter pilots. Because unmanned aircraft are deployed on missions simultaneously with manned aircraft, they can also respond to sudden contingencies.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing