"Seeking Ador's independence cannot be seen as a material breach of the shareholders' agreement"

The court has ruled in favor of former Ador CEO Min Heejin in her legal battle against HYBE.


Min Heejin, former CEO of ADOR. Yonhap News

Min Heejin, former CEO of ADOR. Yonhap News

View original image

On the 12th, the 31st Civil Division of the Seoul Central District Court (Presiding Judge Nam Insoo) ordered HYBE to pay Min approximately 25.5 billion won in put option (stock put option) proceeds. The lawsuit filed by HYBE seeking confirmation of termination of the shareholders' agreement with Min was dismissed.


The court stated, "It can be acknowledged that former CEO Min sought ways to separate Ador from HYBE," but added, "However, that fact alone cannot be viewed as a material breach of the shareholders' agreement in this case."


The court also rejected HYBE's argument that Min intended to carry out an initial public offering (IPO) of Ador after terminating NewJeans' exclusive contract.


The court explained, "It appears that former CEO Min met with external investors and explored ways for Ador to become independent, but all of these appear to have been premised on HYBE's consent," adding, "If HYBE did not agree, such plans could not produce any legal effect."


The court further acknowledged that Min faithfully fulfilled her duties as CEO even while she was in dispute with HYBE. It also found that the suspicions raised by Min regarding ILLIT allegedly copying NewJeans and the alleged forced over-shipment of albums did not constitute grounds for a material breach of contract.


The court said, "The loss that former CEO Min would suffer due to the termination of this contract is relatively clear and significant," but added, "It is difficult to recognize that there was a breach serious enough to justify termination."


The court then ordered HYBE to pay 25.5 billion won to Min. It also ordered HYBE to pay a total of about 3.1 billion won to Min's close associates, former Ador Deputy CEO Shin and former Director Kim, who had likewise notified HYBE of their exercise of put options.


This lawsuit began in November 2024 when Min notified HYBE of her exercise of put options. Under the shareholders' agreement that Min signed, when she exercised the put options she was entitled to receive from HYBE an amount calculated by multiplying Ador's average operating profit for the previous two fiscal years by 13, and then applying 75% of her equity stake in Ador to that figure.



Based on Ador's operating profit in the reference years and the Ador shares held by Min, the amount she is to receive through the exercise of the put options comes to approximately 25.5 billion won.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing