Controversy Over Sales at Prices Above Wholesale Auction Levels... Suspicions of Payments via Spouse and Shifting Card Fees
Even Deductions From Employee Welfare Budget Spark Outcry... Nonghyup Says "Audit Planned in March"

[Exclusive] Nonghyup Asan Co-op Head Faces Allegations of Overpriced Shinhwa Pear Sales and Opaque Settlements View original image

There are allegations that the head of a Nonghyup cooperative in Asan, South Chungcheong Province, sold agricultural products he cultivated through the Nonghyup organization using a sales and settlement structure that was so opaque that even internal employees could not grasp it.


In addition, suspicions have arisen over sales at prices higher than the prevailing market price, deductions from employee welfare expenses, payments made through his spouse, and the passing on to Nonghyup of credit card fees incurred from his personal card payments, prompting criticism that he may have used a public organization for private gain.


According to reporting by The Asia Business Daily and informants on February 12, the cooperative head sold Shinhwa pears he had grown during the Chuseok season in 2025, using the Nonghyup Agricultural Products Processing Center (APC) as his base. Sales were made through the Nonghyup distribution network, an on-site direct sales store on the premises, and his existing private business partners.


The cooperative head and his spouse also personally visited the center to sell to acquaintances and ship products by courier, transporting the pears in a van for sale.


In particular, it was found that the Shinhwa pears, which were trading at around 20,000 to 30,000 won at the wholesale auction market at the time, were sold to consumers at the much higher price of 40,000 to 60,000 won.


However, employees did not know which products were sold to whom or at what price, and suspicions have been raised that these were "blind sales" carried out without any internal sharing of information.


While the sales volume could be checked through the sorting process, some claim that only the cooperative head knew the actual unit sales prices and total sales amount.


Critics also point out that the method of depositing the proceeds from the cooperative head's Shinhwa pear sales deviated from standard procedures.


A Nonghyup official stated, "In principle, payments for products sold through the center must be deposited into the center's bank account."


However, it is reported that for part of the sales proceeds, the business partners first transferred the money to the cooperative head's spouse, and only afterward was it re-deposited into the center's account. The remaining amount was settled by the cooperative head using his personal credit card.


There is also criticism that the credit card fees incurred in this process were booked as Nonghyup expenses, effectively shifting the burden of those fees onto Nonghyup.


In addition, Nonghyup provided the cooperative head's Shinhwa pears as holiday gifts to 50 employees and deducted a total of 1.5 million won from the employee welfare budget, formally treating them as holiday gifts, but effectively selling the pears using employee welfare funds.


Further allegations have been raised that some of the sales proceeds were not deposited immediately and were delayed for several months.


As a result, it is said that various expenses such as sorting costs and labor costs were first paid in advance using Nonghyup funds.


In response, the cooperative head acknowledged, "It is true that I sold the Shinhwa pears for 40,000 to 60,000 won," but claimed, "The price reflected both the quality and the market conditions."


He also argued, "My spouse should be regarded as a sales promotion agent," and explained, "Private business partners deposited the money to my spouse first, and then it was re-deposited into the center's account." He added, "I settled outstanding receivables from pear sales by paying with my personal credit card."



An official at the Nonghyup Chungnam Sejong Regional Headquarters said, "A complaint has been filed, and we plan to audit the cooperative in question in March."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing