Korean Bar Association Holds Forum on Improving Treatment of Court-Appointed Public Defenders
"Delays Due to Budget Shortfalls Are Serious, Substantive Reimbursement of Actual Costs Is Urgently Needed"

The legal community has called for improvements to the court-appointed defense counsel system, including making remuneration for court-appointed public defenders more realistic, checking the current status of delayed payments, and strengthening the review process for appointing such defenders.

Kim Jungwook, president of the Korean Bar Association, is attending the "National Forum on Improving the Treatment of Court-Appointed Public Defenders" at the Korean Bar Association Hall in Seocho-gu, Seoul, on the afternoon of the 11th and is delivering remarks. Photo by Choi Taewon

Kim Jungwook, president of the Korean Bar Association, is attending the "National Forum on Improving the Treatment of Court-Appointed Public Defenders" at the Korean Bar Association Hall in Seocho-gu, Seoul, on the afternoon of the 11th and is delivering remarks. Photo by Choi Taewon

View original image

The Korean Bar Association and the Association of National and Public Court-Appointed Lawyers under the Korean Bar Association held a forum titled "Forum on Improving the Treatment of Nationwide Court-Appointed Public Defenders" at the Bar Association Hall in Seocho-gu, Seoul, on the afternoon of the 11th and made these points. In his opening remarks, Korean Bar Association President Kim Jungwook said that, although court-appointed public defenders are the ones who guarantee the rights of socially disadvantaged people who cannot retain their own counsel, "the demand continues to grow due to the increase in court-appointed cases, but remuneration has been frozen, which is increasing the burden of work and costs, and delays in the payment of fees are worsening difficulties on the ground."


Kim Doyoon, a full-time court-appointed public defender at the Incheon District Court who presented the first paper, first pointed out problems in the remuneration system and budget structure for court-appointed defense. He explained that although the basic remuneration for general court-appointed public defenders has been increased, delayed payment issues are arising due to budget depletion at courts of all levels.


He particularly stressed the need to improve issues such as the cost burden arising from copying massive volumes of evidentiary records and the lack of transparency in reimbursement of actual expenses. He also suggested that limited judicial resources should be used in the right place at the right time, and that predictability and rationality should be enhanced in the process of selecting and operating court-appointed public defenders.


As specific improvement measures, Attorney Kim said, "It is necessary to refine practical procedures such as reviewing certain selection criteria, introducing a cap on the total number of cases, and reimbursing the cost of copying records of at least 10,000 pages," adding, "It is also worth considering ways to reduce unnecessary costs through a comprehensive inspection of facilities."


In the next presentation, Choi Ikgoo, a full-time court-appointed public defender at the Seoul Eastern District Court, introduced concrete examples of hardships faced by court-appointed public defenders in the field. Attorney Choi pointed out that both general court-appointed public defenders and full-time court-appointed public defenders face structural difficulties in areas such as remuneration, budgets, workload, and permission to withdraw from cases. He explained that there have been cases where resignation from a case was not permitted even after the defender suffered verbal abuse or insults from the defendant, and cases where they had to continue performing their duties even while being physically assaulted, indicating that the dignity and safety of court-appointed public defenders are not being adequately protected.


He also mentioned that the strengthening of the principle of trial-centered proceedings has increased both the role and workload of court-appointed public defenders. In other words, the time and effort required to handle cases are increasing. While the burden is growing, he argued that problems are arising from situations where basic remuneration is not paid in a timely manner, increases in remuneration and reimbursement of actual expenses are not sufficiently reflected, and applications for permission to withdraw from cases are denied.


He emphasized that improving the court-appointed defense system is also necessary to ensure the right to assistance of counsel guaranteed by the Constitution and the Criminal Procedure Act. He expressed concern that, without institutional reform, it will not be possible to provide sufficient assistance of counsel to the socially disadvantaged. He also explained that the Supreme Court has previously held that the state has a duty to take necessary measures to ensure that substantial assistance is provided.



Attorney Choi said, "If we rely solely on a sense of duty without adequate remuneration or reimbursement of actual expenses, we cannot guarantee qualitative growth in court-appointed defense," adding, "Only when the budget is expanded and an environment is created in which court-appointed public defenders can focus on their advocacy activities can we ultimately expect to see improved access to justice for suspects and defendants."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing